XR Godalming Update 20th July
July 20, 2021
Dear Godalming Rebels,
Last Friday a committed group of rebels, including from XR Godalming, were intent on protesting at Farnborough Airport at the considerable damage that the aviation industrsendy does to the environment. Disappointingly, the police were sufficiently well-informed to be alert to the action and send officers in considerable numbers to the airport entrances. Under the circumstances, the already high risk action was deemed to be too high risk and called off. Nonetheless, the proposed action, police response and Farnborough airport view all had an airing in Hampshire Live. As often in these situations, there is much to unpack.
Firstly, it is staggering the lengths the police force will go to in order to allow society’s elite to continue to fly. And once again, the police are on the wrong side of the climate debate and protecting the wrong people. It is remarkable they cannot see it. Two years ago Hampshire County Council declared that there is a climate emergency. At the time they expressed the need for ‘being absolutely clear on effective actions we can take to reduce our carbon footprint and make Hampshire more resilient to the effects of climate change already in the system. Our aim is to leave the county in a strong and sustainable position for future generations’. Somehow, council leaders don’t see that having an airport within their council is a problem in that endeavour. Nor do they seem to recognise that XR rebels were doing exactly as they suggested – taking ‘effective actions’. We really need to do more to educate the council.
Secondly, there is the issue of police resources, and no doubt powers had they been necessary, being used pre-emptively and in large numbers to protect the ability of the super-wealthy to pollute the planet and make it uninhabitable for others. Laughably, they claimed that one of their purposes on that day was to ‘facilitate the protesters’ right to lawful protest’. Retrospectively it is perhaps a pity we didn’t put that to the test. But we need to learn, not so much about testing the intention of the police, but about getting our message across. The police were literally there to protect people’s ability to fly. What really needs to happen is that we need to open up the debate about who the climate criminals actually are. The planet has, for some, literally become uninhabitable. It is uninhabitable to people who are washed away in catastrophic floods in Europe. It is uninhabitable for people who expire in the heat of Canada and western USA. It is uninhabitable for children who cannot tolerate the pollution when living along the north circular in London. The people who need protecting are those for whom the planet is no longer habitable, not those who can buy their way out of trouble whilst causing it for others. The police need to direct their resources to the climate criminals, and start with the government in doing this.
Thirdly, there is the utterly disingenuous claim by the Farnborough Airport spokesperson that ‘the airport is carbon neutral for emissions within its control and has recently introduced Sustainable Aviation Fuel (SAF) to support the decarbonisation of the wider industry.’ SAF is being peddled as a panacea for all aviation ills as the fuel is manufactured from non-fossil-fuel elements. For those who are interested, an organisation called Biofuelwatch gives a very good account of why SAF is not what the aviation industry or government claim it to be in terms of a solution to the climate crisis. SAF takes a lot of land and energy to manufacture, and the extent to which manufacturers claim it mitigates the emissions issues of aeroplanes rarely takes into account the wider problem beyond CO2. Biofuelwatch asserts that ‘the best contemporary science regarding aviation climate impacts shows that the full climate impact of jet flight is three times that of the warming from the CO2 emissions. This is due to the radiative forcing impact of the combustion of fuels, including biofuels, at high altitudes.’ So even if actual CO2 emissions are mitigated, for example through supposedly carbon-neutral fuels, the impact on the atmosphere of burning fuel at a high altitude is not. Inevitably, what we will hear about SAF, will be tantamount to a shed load of greenwashing. Again, we need to get a strong and clear message out about this, as the lobbyists and marketers are hard at work and many people won’t inform themselves of the truth.
Fourthly, is the issue of lobbyists. It is no surprise that companies such as Shell and BP are at the forefront of SAF. But they are not the only ones. And they will lobby governments hard to be allowed to produce and sell this fuel with the irresistible inducement that we can all carry on travelling as we have, but without damaging the planet. For politicians, that is the Holy Grail. In launching the government’s Transport Decarbonisation Plan last week, the Transport Secretary announced that ‘it is not about stopping people doing things: it’s about doing the same things differently. We will still fly on holiday, but in more efficient aircraft, using sustainable fuel.’ This is delusional claptrap! Not surprisingly, SAF and carbon offsets (really no time to get in to that as well right now!!) are the central planks to UK government plans to create a carbon neutral aviation industry. In the meantime, we are increasingly learning more about the machinations of the oil companies. The Guardian recently published an article on the role of lobby groups on behalf of oil companies. In the USA, lobbyists are already on Biden’s back to provide funding to SAF producers in order to decarbonise the aviation industry. And of course, we’ll find old enemies in amongst those who are looking for those subsidies. We are close to the perverse situation where companies that have profited immensely from selling fossil fuels are going to receive grants from the government to invest in biofuels that won’t actually solve the problem – give us strength!
What does all of this mean for us? It means we need to keep our resolve. It means we need to work harder to get the core messages across so that people know the truth about the planet and our plight. It means we need to be fleet of foot when we are confronted with the misdirected strong arm of the law. And it means we need to keep our own community strong, healthy and nourishing so that we don’t lose heart in the campaigns we need to fight.
On which note, as reported last week, XRUK is ramping up preparation for The Impossible Rebellion in London from 23 August. The nature of the action is evolving and the current outline can be read here. The target is the City of London and its financial institutions. There will be a range of different types of actions to suit all rebels. A high turnout will be needed, and the rebellion has the aim to start big, and then get bigger. We discussed The Impossible rebellion last week, and will continue our discussion this week.
Of course, it would be hard in a newsletter penned on 19 July not to mention Covid restrictions being eased. We can meet in person without restrictions. On top of that, the weather is good this week. At last week’s meeting we agreed that this week we would meet at the bandstand in Godalming. It would be great to have a good turnout to talk about how we follow up from the Farnborough event last week, and how we continue to plan for The Impossible Rebellion.
____________________
Meeting this week – Wednesday 21 July
PLEASE NOTE – WE ARE MEETING AT THE BANDSTAND IN GODALMING AT 7.30pm. Feel free to bring your own refreshments along.
At the meeting we will focus on:
- Whether we want to do any actions at Farnborough following last week’s actions being called off.
- Continuing our discussions about, and preparations for the August/Impossible rebellion.
Last week we started discussing the August/Impossible rebellion. A few details about what we know so far are in the project board below. Our thoughts on the rebellion included:
- Do street corner talks
- Somehow include citizens’ assemblies
- Do something locally to help people understand what is happening nationally, perhaps ahead of the event
- Can we derive some capital out of the notion that there is a Bank Holiday, given that it is financial institutions that are the target (how could they better spend their time than taking a day off?)
- Do some discobedience
- Try to get people to pledge to making changes
- Try and get actions/activities that can be repeated as vignettes/on a carousel basis
- Include Farnham and Guildford (and other local groups) in our plans/actions
There is room for more ideas and creativity, so please come to the bandstand and share your thoughts.
____________________
Project board
As we meander through the summer we are gradually working our way through the actions on the project board. We have an aviation coming up and after that we have a quieter spell until the national August rebellion.
If there is a project you are aware of that we should include, please email xrgodalming@gmail.com.
The Impossible Rebellion, London, August 23rd onwards – see above and via this link.
What we know so far is that this will run for two weeks.
The idea is to start big and end bigger!
The focus is on the City of London and financial institutions.
There will be events every day in London over the two weeks.
Local and regional groups are invited to develop and submit ideas to XRUK.
26th August is a big SE region day, so as many people as possible on that day in particular would be great.
There is a planned link with XR Scandinavia.
REGIONAL ACTIONS
Kill the Bill Surrey – ongoing
Kill the Bill Surrey has now set up an Instagram account where you can keep in touch with what this excellent movement is doing, and when. We will also put information about protests in the newsletter and the general chat on Telegram.
Guildford is probably the only town in Surrey that has regular protests against the new Police, Crime, Sentencing and Courts (PCSC) Bill. The PCSC Bill is designed to introduce new police powers and review the rules around crime and justice across England and Wales.
It proposes wide-ranging new police powers when it comes to protests, such as the ability to impose “conditions” on any protest which is deemed to be disruptive to the local community and up to 10 years in prison for damaging memorials, such as statues.
LOCAL ACTIONS
No Idling. We have recently put signs up in Godalming.
We have had considerable success with ‘no idling signs’ and have loads more to put up. We need to coordinate further actions as we have loads of signs to put up if we want.
Peat. Contact Alyson or Chris.
Some great action on this over the past few weeks, and this has started some dialogue with local garden centres. The action is ongoing and there is room for more people to be involved. Here’s why it’s important:
Despite the introduction of a voluntary peat code about 10 years ago, a lot of peat is still used in the UK. Peat bogs need to be restored, not dug up; they are amazing carbon sinks as well as being important habitats. The plan is for several action opportunities for small groups or pairs outside different shops on different days.
There has been recent positive news about peat. Sales of peat in compost will be banned for gardeners from 2024. As ever with government targets, it falls short of what’s really needed, which is for all gardeners to stop using peat-based composts now. We just don’t need them. Everybody who knows anything about peat is ahead of the government on this, including celebrity gardeners and the Wildlife Trusts. Many people want to go peat free, but the government has set an unambitious target and retailers still market peat-based products ahead of the peat-free ones.
Local Banner Actions. ongoing as and when. Contact Rieks
We have some great sites in and around Godalming that we have used, as well as doing banner drops from bridges over the A3. If you have a spare hour or two then please join in at some point.
PROJECTS
COP Local. In development. Starting summer onwards. Contact Rieks.
Godalming Friends of the Land. In development. Contact Carol
Video Outreach. Ongoing. Contact Louisa
XR4 Sustainable Economy. Ongoing. Contact Karen
With hope and determination,
XR Godalming