XR Godalming Update 27th July

Dear Godalming Rebels,

Last week’s newsletter started with information about the planned action for 16th July at Farnborough Airport which did not go ahead due to the large police presence. It has left a feeling of unfinished business for rebels in Godalming, and those at XR Fleet, Farnborough and Camberley (FFC). We are therefore doing two things. Firstly, FFC rebels are organising a day of action at the airport this Saturday, 31st July. This will start at 10 am at the Ivesley roundabout. Anyone interested in joining and who isn’t on the Telegram group for this action please contact Charles, or email xrgodalming@gmail.com. As with all actions, it would be great to have a large presence. We didn’t carry out our actions on July 16th, but we are not giving up our campaign against flying and private jets. Secondly, we are going to try and get a response into the local paper to counter the claim by the airport spokesperson that the use of sustainable aviation fuel (SAF) is a way of decarbonising the aviation industry. The letter draws on the information from last week’s newsletter leader and is included at the end of this one for information.

While we are getting on with tackling the climate and ecological crisis, the government is pressing ahead with SAF. On Friday last week the government announced a £15 million fund available for companies to produce SAF to a commercial scale. This is part of a Green Fuel Green Skies competition. Of course, this is timed carefully to enable the government to show its green credentials ahead of COP26, and with the carrot of producing 1000 jobs, including in the north of the country (levelling up?). We are in really dangerous territory here. The International Council for Clean Transportation says that current availability of waste material will only meet 5.5% of demand for aviation biofuel by 2030. Coupled with that, other energy sectors, such as district power supplies and road freight will compete for the same ‘feedstocks’ to create biofuels. Because we have an economic system based on continuous growth, we will be in the mind-bending situation where we will need continually to create more waste to fuel our ever increasing energy needs, for which we will need continually to create more waste…. This is a calamitous form of vicious cycle for the planet. Inevitably, SAF from other feedstocks are coming onto the market, such as from palm oil. This is another disaster as palm oil production goes hand-in-hand with rainforest destruction, so there is absolutely nothing sustainable about it.

The Royal Academy of Engineering, in its recent report on the sustainability of liquid biofuels, says that ‘most sustainability studies of biofuels to date have focused on their environmental impacts and, in particular, on the carbon footprint’, by which they mean at the point of use. They believe there are ‘significant sustainability issues associated with liquid biofuels’. They recognise the considerable work still to be done to evaluate, over the full ecological life-cycle of biofuels, the environmental impact of this energy source:

Even focusing only on the carbon footprint of biofuels – one of the main drivers for their development – brings with it a host of uncertainties. Moreover, almost every aspect related to biofuels is dynamic in nature across different scales, which adds to the complexity. Examples include changes in soil carbon content over time (micro-scale); time needed to replace vegetation used as feedstock for biofuels (meso-scale); and development of global biofuel supply chains (macro-scale). Considering these dynamic aspects and their interconnections presents a considerable challenge.

Biofuels may, in the long term, be part of the world’s energy supply, but the government is presenting them as if the technology to make them in a truly sustainable way already exists. They fail to take into account the competing demands for the feedstock. For example, any human food waste used to create energy cannot then be used for other purposes, such as animal feeds. They fail to take into account the fact that burning anything causes pollution, no matter what type of fuel you use. And they fail to take in to account the responsibility that wealthy countries and individuals have for significantly reducing their carbon emissions right now, not by 2050, because as we can see in daily news items, the impact of climate change is happening today. Pollution inequality isn’t even on the government agenda at this point, and recent cuts to foreign aid will only exacerbate this problem.

Tackling inequality and campaigning against funding of fossil fuels remain XR’s biggest priorities at the moment. The latter is the theme for the Impossible Rebellion in August. It is because of the destructive legacy of past and continued financing of fossil fuel extraction and burning that XR has a new immediate demand: “Stop all new fossil fuel investment immediately, supporting a just transition.” At the XR Godalming meeting held last week we agreed that we would do local outreach actions in the run up to the Impossible Rebellion and plan the actions we will participate in during the rebellion. For now, this is the focus of our time and energy. Because of the importance and urgency of the Impossible Rebellion, this newsletter primarily contains information about what we are doing, and how you can be involved.

____________________

Contents

  1. Meeting this week on Wednesday by zoom
  2. Impossible Rebellion – Getting ready to rebel!
  3. Draft article for Hampshire Live

Meeting this week – Wednesday 21 July

PLEASE NOTE – WE ARE MEETING VIA ZOOM THIS WEEK

As discussed last week when we met at the bandstand, we will continue to focus on preparations for the Impossible Rebellion. Please read the details about this below; it’s evolving all the time, but we do have some plans already.

If you haven’t attended a meeting for a while, it would be great to see you. We will be joined by rebels from Farnham and Guildford who are going to help in the preparation for the Impossible rebellion, and will join us in London.

The meeting will start at 7.15 pm for new members or those who want to chat before we start.

The main meeting will start at 7.30pm

Join the Zoom Meeting
https://us02web.zoom.us/j/86156165509

Meeting ID: 861 5616 5509

____________________

The Impossible Rebellion – Getting Ready to Rebel!

What are we doing?

The August Rebellion starts August 23rd and will last for up to 2 weeks. There will be actions that XR Godalming rebels can join in with on all or most days. Most of the action will be in London but there could also be actions locally or in other locations. The details are being worked out and are gradually coming together. Plans are being developed by a variety of different XR working groups, regional groups and local groups (including ours!) and will be brought together in one ‘programme’ by the XR Rebellion Weavers. As soon as we know more detail, we’ll tell you. If you’re on the ‘central XR’ mailing lists and/or the Telegram national Rebellion Broadcast you will also get information that way

When are people going to London?

The likelihood is that varying numbers of Godalming rebels will ‘commute’ to and from London on various rebellion days and that some will find places to stay in London for convenience. XR is currently working on sourcing suitable campsites for those who want to do that and will help people who want to stay ‘indoors’ to find suitable free/very cheap accommodation through a ‘hosting’ system. Please contact Chris if you want to find out more about this.

How is XR Godalming getting organised?

A number of things, outlined below, will be happening over the next 4 weeks to get us ready to rebel:

OUTREACH AND RECRUITMENT

We’ll be doing actions in local high streets on each Saturday in the build up to the rebellion – giving out leaflets, displaying banners, giving short-talks and presentations, and explaining to the people we meet what we are doing and why. Anyone and everyone can be involved with this. The more people who join in with this, the more extra interest and support we will get.

We’ll be doing banner-drops in the local areas on many weekday mornings to publicise our group and the rebellion. This is an easy, time-efficient and enjoyable way to spend an hour or two, have a chat to friends and still have the rest of the day free. We’ve got a great new banner for the rebellion ‘the rebellion continues – London – from 23 August’ which we will display.

We’ll be pushing our message and promoting the rebellion on social media. Everyone who has a social media account can help this effort by spreading posts about the rebellion and putting them on community boards and the like where perhaps they wouldn’t normally be found. Our media group needs more people to help right now. If you can join our Media Working Group and help with social media or with writing letters to, and articles for the press, including the local press, then please get involved with this.

WORKING TOGETHER, SUPPORTING AND LOOKING AFTER EACH OTHER

As in previous London rebellions, we’ll use an Affinity Group system to make sure that people can stay connected to one another, give each other practical and emotional support, share transport and stay safe. Exactly how we organise this is going to depend on information that we get from YOU about how you want to be involved. Everyone on our mailing list will have received or will be receiving an email from XR Godalming asking you some questions about how you might want to be involved. Please help us by replying.

For this rebellion, we are exploring how we can work together with our friends from XR Farnham, XR Guildford and possibly other nearby groups so as to make the best use of the resources we have between us. We feel we’ll be stronger together and we’ll be working out the details of this over the next couple of meetings

SHARING THE LOAD AND BEING ONE OF THE CREW.

Some people might go to London every day. Some people might not go at all. There are loads of jobs and roles which need doing – in the big city and/or at home. Everyone can do something and however ‘small’ you think your contribution might be it’s important to us. We need everyone. This is a Rebellion and XR’s key mode of operation is protest thorough peaceful civil disobedience. It’s true that we need people to sit in the road (and other creatively disruptive places!). But we also need people to:

design leaflets and posters, stick them up and give them out

make phone calls and write emails

hold banners and go on marches

be a ‘Police Liaison’ person

support arrestees in person at police stations or through the ‘back-office’ system

organise and manage the group and maintain communication from the ‘back-office’ (your house!)

provide practical and emotional/pastoral support for others in the group (“Wellbeing”)

post on social media, write to newspapers, talk to your friends, colleagues and neighbours

give talks and lead discussions

help to set-up/run websites

design, build, make, display and transport ‘stuff’ of all kinds!

make banners, flags, placards, costumes, and other ‘art’ work…..

perform – music, street theatre, etc.

take photographs, make and edit videos and ‘livestreams’

keep people calm, make them tea, make them laugh (or cry), dance, sing, shout, meditate

… do something not on this list that you can do. Whatever you can do, WE NEED YOU

HELPING TO PLAN AND ORGANISE ACTIONS

There is always loads of work required to design, create and organise an effective action. Anyone can get involved in this. All voices are helpful, including the ones that say “No, that won’t work”. If you have an idea for an action, please tell us and we can help you make it happen. People in the group are already talking about plans for street-talks, street-theatre, public outreach actions and more ‘traditional’ disruptive protests. The overall context /theme for this rebellion has been set as actions which target financing the climate crisis (the City of London) and which use the motif of ‘Crisis Talks’ (think animated discussion around pink table in the street.) But hey, this is Extinction Rebellion, and as long you stick to our principles and values you can do whatever you want…..

DOING WHAT YOU CAN DO…….

Whether your skills are ‘soft’ or ‘hard’, ‘technical’ or ‘traditional’; whether you’re an administrator or a cook, a mechanic or a carpenter, a writer or an artist, a gardener or a builder, a teacher or a therapist, a politician or a speaker, a musician or a drummer, a youth or a parent or a grandparent or a great-grandparent, a do-er or a thinker – WE NEED YOU.

So, please respond to the email that you will receive/have received asking whether and how YOU want to be involved in the August rebellion and/or the preparations for it. If you can come to some of the meetings we will be holding in the build-up then that’s great but if not you can still easily be involved. Every small thing you do will help. There has never been a more important time to ACT than this. Hope to see you soon!

____________________

Draft article for Hampshire Live

On 16 July Hampshire Live reported on Extinction Rebellion’s plans to protest at Farnborough Airport, and the actions taken by police to intercept this action. In the article, a spokesperson for the airport was quoted as saying that ‘the airport is carbon neutral for emissions within its control and has recently introduced Sustainable Aviation Fuel to support the decarbonisation of the wider industry.’ As there was no Extinction Rebellion presence at the airport on that day, Hampshire Live did not request, nor seek any views beyond those of the police and airport authorities. We therefore wish to make a contribution to the debate about the environmental and climate impact of flying and specifically the use private jets, and the flawed notion that sustainable aviation fuels are a solution to the decarbonisation of the aviation industry.

Extinction Rebellion is concerned about the impact of aviation on the climate, and even more so the impact of private jets. Our focus on Farnborough Airport is not random, but for good reason. Aviation contributes just over 2% of global carbon emissions. That may not seem high to some people, but continued plans for airport expansions and increased flying mean this figure is set to rise, just at the point when climate scientists and political leaders agree that we need to reduce carbon emissions, not increase them. In May 2021, a Transport and Environment report found that on average private jets are 10 times more carbon intensive than commercial airliners, and a staggering 50 times more polluting than trains. Added to that is the fact that the rate of increase of CO2 from private jets is faster than for commercial airliners. European private jet CO2 emissions increased 31% between 2005 and 2019.

Regarding sustainable aviation fuel (SAF), the assertion by Farnborough Airport that this contributes to decarbonisation needs at a minimum to be debated, if not actually challenged. SAF is being presented as a panacea for all aviation ills as the fuel is manufactured from non-fossil-fuel ‘feedstocks’. However, this is to fail to see the wider issues of SAF beyond a ‘tail-pipe’ emissions view. An organisation called Biofuelwatch has researched the impact of SAF and why it is not what the aviation industry or government claim it to be in terms of a solution to the climate crisis. SAF is manufactured from a range of feedstocks. These include a variety of waste products, including municipal waste and waste cooking oil. However, to keep the current stock of aeroplanes flying will take much more waste than is available, so crop feedstocks are necessary to make up the considerable shortfall. This takes a lot of land, which will either take away from land needed to feed people, rather than needlessly fly them, or will be taken from the few areas of the planet’s remaining wildernesses. Both options are unacceptable. The mono-cultural form of farming that would be used for large scale SAF production will, as with all such farming, further accelerate the planet’s already critical biodiversity loss. On top of the negative environmental damage that producing SAF causes, the extent to which manufacturers claim it mitigates the emissions issues of aeroplanes rarely takes into account the wider problem beyond CO2. Biofuelwatch asserts that ‘the best contemporary science regarding aviation climate impacts shows that the full climate impact of jet flight is three times that of the warming from the CO2 emissions. This is due to the radiative forcing impact of the combustion of fuels, including biofuels, at high altitudes.’ So even if actual CO2 emissions are mitigated, for example through supposedly carbon-neutral fuels, the impact on the atmosphere of burning fuel at a high altitude is not. Inevitably, what we will hear about SAF, will be tantamount to greenwashing.

Even if it is true that over time SAF will provide a sustainable way to fly, this is a long way off, and Farnborough Airport needs to tell the truth about that. The International Council on Clean Transportation estimates that 5.5% of aviation fuel in the EU could come from sustainable sources by 2030. The planet cannot wait for the aviation industry to become carbon neutral as it is in crisis now. We currently face an existential threat through the damage we have done to the environment and the climate. As such, we need to adjust our behaviour immediately to avert that threat and, among other things, substantially reduce the amount we fly. The Transport Secretary, when launching the UK’s Transport Decarbonisation Plan, announced that ‘it is not about stopping people doing things: it’s about doing the same things differently. We will still fly on holiday, but in more efficient aircraft, using sustainable fuel.’ This is dangerous and delusional. SAF, carbon offsets and other supposed quick-fix measures will not save us from the trouble we are in. That is why Extinction Rebellion demands that the government acts now to avert the climate and ecological crisis. That is why we target sites such as Farnborough Airport, and demand that those who pollute the most, take most responsibility for changing their behaviour. That is why we welcome continued and open debate so that we are all informed of the truth, and can commit to actions that will make a meaningful difference.  

With hope and determination,

XR Godalming