COP26: Lights! Camera! Rhetoric!
November 01, 2021
Lights! Camera! Rhetoric! COP26 is off to a limping start. The rhetoric we hear is of ‘leading by example’, ‘last chance to save the planet’, ‘digging our own graves’, ‘one minute to midnight’ etc. The reality is that the combined targets (and we haven’t even got round to actions to achieve these) won’t be enough to save the planet. The reality is that despite making progress, India is going to be 20 years behind the global target to get to net zero by 2050, and the 2050 target itself is around 20 years behind what the planet can sustain. The reality is that even the hyper-green-ever-enlarging-epiphany-struck Prime Minister says that “currently, let’s be in no doubt, we are not going to hit it [a deal/suitable target] and we have to be honest with ourselves.” The commitments being made so far were a “drop in the rapidly warming ocean”.

The problem we have is an obvious one, it’s the ‘say/do’ gap, where what politicians, policy makers, business and other world leaders do fails to match up to what they say. The result is a lack of trust. The result is also that we remain in utter peril. It’s not surprising that the leaders of poorer countries don’t trust what those from richer countries say, when the latter have not come up with the pledged $100 billion a year from 2020 to help the former reduce their carbon emissions. The say/do gap is so blatant and staggering that it’s remarkable politicians get away with it. Here’s a quote that we’d all like to believe could lead to meaningful action: ‘What I am saying is that instead of making excuses tomorrow to our children and grandchildren, we should be taking action against climate change today. What we are looking for is not difficult. It is doable and therefore we should come together and do it’.
Did the person who said that follow through? No. That was the then prime minister, David Cameron, in his closing address in December 2015 at COP 21, which spawned the Paris Agreement. Just three months later – that needs repeating, just three months later in the budget delivered in March 2016 the Chancellor of the Exchequer, George Osborne, announced that Petroleum Revenue Tax would be abolished. This was a tax levied on North Sea oil and gas companies, amongst them Shell and BP. On top of this tax break, companies received UK government support to decommission rigs. The outcome of this is that Shell and BP, who between them produce more than 1.7bn tonnes of greenhouse gases a year, paid no corporation tax or production levies on North Sea oil operations between 2018 and 2020; they claimed tax reliefs of nearly £400m; they paid out more than £44bn in dividends to shareholders. That is beyond shameful. The say/do gap was so monumental it’s a wonder there were no protests on the streets. Sadly, XR didn’t exist then.
We should be under no illusion that just because the faces in the government’s cabinet are different, that their behaviour has changed. We already know the rhetoric is the same. And we know the behaviour is the same. Five days before the UK was due to host COP26 (remember the rhetoric from earlier, last chance to save the blah, blah, blah, as Greta Thunberg might say) the Chancellor of the Exchequer, Rishi Sunak, failed to mention climate change once in his budget speech. Nor did he provide any funding, direct or indirect, towards solving the climate crisis. He failed further by reducing air passenger duty on short-haul flights. He failed to increase fuel duty for cars which has now remained unchanged for twelve consecutive years. He failed to put any new funds into insulating the country’s housing stock. And he failed by committing £2.6 billion to road projects.
It is unlikely that the government will ever get away with a say/do gap of the proportions they did in 2015/16 without being held to account for it because XR is on their case, along with a host of other energetic campaign groups. It may be exhausting standing up to the behemoth that is the establishment but it is necessary and we will come out in numbers on the streets to campaign and protest. It is argued that one of the reasons governments fail to act on climate change is because they only have an eye on short term gains to secure electoral success. Up until now, for reasons that seem unfathomable, not enough people have seen climate change as an important enough electoral issue. What that shows is that the political system is flawed and we can’t rely on it to solve our existential crisis. We also know that our economic system is flawed (see above!). We need system change and XR has known that all along. Our third demand is to go beyond politics. Government must create and be led by the decisions of a Citizens’ Assembly on climate and ecological justice.
COP26 is all over the news. We have to seize the chance to educate and influence as many people as we can to become activists. We can afford no more say/do gaps. We don’t need any more rhetoric. We need: Lights! Camera! ACTION!