Much to fear and much to be hopeful for
May 16, 2022
In a recent edition of the Farnham Herald someone wrote in to complain that XR’s efforts are misdirected. They argued that because the UK contribution to carbon emissions is low relative to that of countries such as China, we should focus on the most polluting countries. We face that spurious argument quite a bit. What that person fails to recognise is the global damage done by UK fossil fuel and finance companies, the fact that much of what is consumed in the UK is manufactured abroad so we have effectively displaced our carbon emissions, and that if there is to be leadership in reaching net zero, every country has to meet its agreed carbon emissions targets. Perhaps explaining carbon budgets might be a way to get people to think about national, local and personal responsibility. The argument might go a bit like this:
The principles of effective budgeting are simple: if you can’t afford it, don’t buy it. If you have to go over your budget, know how you will get back to break even. If you have to make a reduction, everyone should contribute to managing the cuts. Those who start with the largest share, should make the largest cuts.
We all know that to stave off the worst impacts of climate change, we have to cut carbon emissions. To reach net zero by 2050, the government has set legally binding caps on the amount of greenhouse gases to be emitted in the UK over a series of five-year periods. This is referred to as the carbon budget.
The UK caps are reflected in local authority targets. Waverley Borough Council’s aim to reach net zero by 2050 requires a minimum year-on-year reduction in carbon emissions of 13.4%. Councillors have also set a more challenging, and arguably very necessary target to achieve net zero by 2030. This needs a 27% year-on-year reduction in carbon emissions.
There is no point any of us hoping that someone else will make those reductions, so that we don’t have to. Equally, we need to help people understand that anyone who chooses to maintain a high carbon lifestyle is effectively seeing themselves as somehow more entitled to a greater share of the carbon budget than other people. This argument works globally as well as locally, and is a cause of climate injustice.
An easy example for us to illustrate climate injustice is flying. Someone who takes a return flight from London to New York will use roughly the same amount of the global carbon budget as the average person living in Ghana uses in one year. That is an injustice. The injustice is compounded further because Ghanaians suffer more through climate change than we do, despite their lower personal and national impact. Ghanaians are experiencing increased droughts, raised temperatures and extreme weather events. These are causing food and water insecurity.
We have a moral duty, as people with high carbon lifestyles, to lower significantly the amount of the carbon budget we claim for ourselves in the choices we make. We could continue along the travel route to get this point across. Switching from flying to train travel, for example, has a dramatic impact. Train journeys from London to places such as Edinburgh, Paris or Madrid use around 75% less of the carbon budget per passenger than flights to the same destinations.
Our choice of car (leaving aside for a moment that we should massively reduce our dependence on cars) can also make a huge difference. Typically, someone who chooses to buy a new, small hatchback will use around 6 to 10 tonnes of the carbon budget in its manufacture. If they chose to buy a new, large SUV they are claiming a whopping 35 tonnes of the carbon budget for themselves. Then, once they have bought a large vehicle, whether it is powered by petrol, diesel, hybrid or electricity, because of its size and weight, it will use about 14% more energy to drive than a smaller, medium sized, similarly powered car. We have to ask the (rhetorical) question. Is that fair?
When we talk to people on the streets, we are often told that the UK is doing well in reducing carbon emissions and that other countries need to do more. It is true that carbon emissions in the UK are reducing and that arguably some other countries need to do more. However, that is no reason for people not to minimise, in line with national and Waverley targets, their personal consumption of the carbon budget.
Last week we ruminated on the fact that six months after COP26, not much has been written in the media about what progress has been made at the halfway stage to the next COP. Someone at The Guardian must read this newsletter, because on Saturday they published two articles on the subject. In one, they reviewed the progress made in the four priority areas, cash, coal, cars, and trees. We could probably summarise this as follows: not enough; getting worse, especially in light of the war in Ukraine; more people are buying EVs but the focus should have been on transport infrastructure, not cars; going backwards, especially with the increase in deforestation of the Amazon. On Saturday they also published an article about what needs to be achieved at COP27. In summary: if governments don’t switch rapidly to sustainable/renewable energy sources, then we’re screwed!
This newsletter isn’t intended to be an advert for The Guardian, but their investigative journalism has uncovered the rather inevitable, and extremely terrifying intentions of fossil fuel companies and what are being termed ‘carbon bombs’. With the price of oil high, and fossil fuel companies’ first priority being a return on investment for shareholders, they see a massive opportunity to make huge amounts of money. They are in no mood to leave any oil and gas reserves in the ground, and they are exploiting the current energy crisis as a reason for expanding their operation.
It’s vitally important for us to know about the dangers we face. Equally, it is important for us not to become overwhelmed and to allow climate anxiety to consume us. In the WAB telegram chat there has been some really helpful signposting to people who are writing or talking about active hope. This one from Resurgence and Ecologist, is particularly good on staying hopeful in a time of crisis. One of the things that should give us hope, and give us the determination to talk to the public and agitate governments, is the fact that we know viable solutions are already available. It’s a matter of will. An excellent example is given in an article in Rethink Disruption, which explains how even the largest EU country can go to 100% clean energy by 2035 for less that the amount spent on fossil fuels.
We have much to fear and much to be hopeful for. Another world is possible!
____________________
CONTENTS
- Meeting this Wednesday via Zoom
- Dates for the diary
- Wellbeing
- What’s on at the climate emergency centres
- Sit for Climate
____________________
MEETING THIS WEEK – Wednesday 18th May
We will have a Zoom meeting this week on Wednesday 18th May.
The meeting will open at 7.15 pm and will start at 7.30pm.
Join the Zoom Meeting
https://us02web.zoom.us/j/86156165509
Meeting ID: 861 5616 5509
By way of explanation, we had originally planned to alternate between in person and zoom meetings. The XR WAB working group made a decision recently to stick with zoom meetings on Wednesdays for now, as they generally enable more people to participate. We felt this was doable because we are seeing each other fairly frequently at, for example, marches round the houses, the various local fairs/festivals coming up, SitForClimate and so on. When it is helpful for us to have an in-person meeting, we will do so. Hopefully that suits people in the group.
Last week we had a good meeting to start looking at our summer plans and actions we think we could do before the September rebellion. We need to make these a reality. A summary of our thoughts is:
- More tube poster actions – we need to see if we can get hold of the designs as will need to print more.
- More marches round the houses. This does need more people to be involved to talk to the public.
- Rebel ringing – Tom is looking into this and can link to both local/summer uprising events and then build up to the September rebellion.
- Working with other local groups on actions – Surrey/SE.
- Be present at local festivals – we are reasonably well under way with this (see below).
- Kicking the can down the road – Rosie brought this creative idea to the group, and we felt we should see if we can make it a reality – probably needs a group to design it.
- We have some other stuff we can build in quite easily, for example rush-hour banners.
Please come to the meeting and help prioritise the ones we think will have the biggest impact and then to plan them.
On Sunday 22nd May we have a stall at the Farnham Sustainability Festival. This is a great opportunity for us to talk to people who are already ‘close to us’. Please help if you can as we continue the push to swell our number during the summer and in readiness for the September rebellion. We may spend some time on Wednesday planning for this event, which has arrived on our calendar slightly at the last minute.
____________________
Dates for the diary
As well as any actions we agree to do as part of the summer uprising and preparation for the September rebellion, we already have some firm dates in the diary for outreach. As ever, we need as many people as possible to help recruit new rebels. These are:
Sunday 22nd May – Farnham Sustainability Festival
Friday 3rd June – Haslemere Charter Fair
Saturday 18th June – Samba march around the houses
Saturday 9th July – Godalming Climate Forum Day
Saturday 13th August – Godalming Green Gala
Saturday 10th September onwards – REBELLION!
____________________
Wellbeing
On the 21st and 22nd May the wellbeing group is organising a ‘regenerative camping weekend’. This is a great opportunity to spend a night socialising, star gazing and camping in a very rural setting. If you do not already know of the event and want to join in, then please email xrgodalming@gmail.com and we’ll share more information with you.
____________________
What’s on at the climate emergency centres
What Next? in Waverley and Zero in Guildford continue to increase their range of activities. Check out their websites for latest activities.

Thank you to everyone who came to the What Next Lounge in Crown Court in Godalming on Saturday. As with all outreach, whether XR badged or not, this was another great opportunity to talk to the public about the climate emergency. We used the climate change ‘concern’ chart which is a brilliant hook to get conversations started. We continue to see the same outcomes; most people are at least a 7 on the chart. Many people are terrified. Sadly, most of the children who responded are terrified, which is a dreadful indictment of what we have done to the future of young people. Many older people said they were terrified not for themselves, but for their children and grandchildren. We met people in their 20s and 30s who said they won’t have children. They are concerned about the world their children would grow up in from a climate perspective. Despite feeling this way, we are struggling to get these people to take more action in their lives to bring about the change they would like to see. We need to consider further what strategies we can use to bring those people closer to taking action.
____________________
#SitForClimate
SitForClimate has regained its pre-rebellion momentum and many XR WAB rebels take part. A number combined it with helping at the What Next Lounge, where we were able to encourage a few passers-by to join.

The great thing about #SitForClimate is that you can do it anywhere! If you are not already ‘sitting’ on Saturday mornings, please think about joining. It’s another way of nudging conversations with people towards the climate. Here’s what it’s all about:
Everyone; Everywhere; Every week
#SitForClimate is a movement for people to show their concern about the climate crisis by joining in a short, regular, inclusive action.
WHEN: Every Saturday, 11am, for 10 minutes.
WHAT: Sit anywhere you like and display the #SitforClimate message on a home-made sign or on your phone. Sit on your own or with others.
To see what happened on Saturday, go to:
https://www.instagram.com/sitforclimate/
https://www.facebook.com/groups/344176940895550