The Things They Say
March 11, 2024
It’s amazing how politicians and business leaders want to tell us what we think. We’ve had a spate of it recently. Yesterday, the former Tory MP Lee Anderson defected to Reform UK. Richard Tice, Reform UK’s leader, gave a catalogue of reasons why that defection took place. Among these he asserted that ‘people are concerned about the cost of net-zero’. How does an unelected leader of a party that has got one MP by default know what people think about net-zero? Anderson used the moment of his defection to repeat his extraordinarily racist views (‘we are letting people into our country that will never integrate or adopt our British values’) and claim these were ‘opinions which are shared by millions of people up and down the country’. Really?
Last week, Darren Woods, chief executive of fossil fuel giant Exxon Mobil, also seemed to think he knew what people’s attitude to the climate crisis is. He said that “the dirty secret nobody talks about is how much all this is going to cost and who’s willing to pay for it. The people who are generating those emissions need to be aware of and pay the price for generating those emissions… When are people going to be willing to pay for carbon reduction?” The bare-faced lies of those assumptions really need challenging. Let’s deal with ‘dirty secrets’ first. In 2015 it was revealed that since the 1970s Exxon Mobil knew of the direct link between burning fossil fuels and climate breakdown. Unsurprisingly, since the company makes billions from selling fossil fuels, they kept this knowledge secret. That’s the real dirty secret here.
Then ‘who’s willing to pay for it’. The price we will pay for inaction on the climate crisis won’t be measured in monetary terms. We’ll be paying with the lives of millions of people, animals and plants. We’ll be paying with life on earth as we know it. If we do confine the notion of ‘paying’ to the narrow world of finance, which is the only bottom line that people like Woods care about, then the obvious answer is that Exxon Mobil and all other fossil fuel companies and their enablers should pay. Last month Exxon posted 2023 profits of $36 billion. In 2022 the biggest oil companies between then made profits of around $200 billion. To the question, ‘who’s willing to pay for it’, the point is moot. Research done in 2021 concluded that among the public ‘there is a willingness to change day to day lives to accommodate a reduction in carbon emissions, but no consensus on how to pay for net zero. An honest conversation is expected by the public when it comes to new projects and the transition to net zero.’ Not much has changed around the need for an honest conversation and it wouldn’t be surprising if there was still no consensus on how to pay for net zero. But let’s reframe the question ever so slightly and ask ‘who should pay?’ That’s easy, because the people most responsible for carbon emissions, the people who have profited the most, the people who have the most money to pay, are the fossil fuel giants. It’s a familiar trope of right-wing politicians and of fossil fuel executives that the move to sustainable energy will result in higher costs for the general public. It just isn’t true.
Another area where we are hearing the most outrageous and worrying things is on the definition of extremism, which is the current pre-occupation of Michael Gove, Secretary of State for Levelling Up, Housing and Communities. Here’s the proposed definition: “Extremism is the promotion or advancement of any ideology which aims to overturn or undermine the UK’s system of parliamentary democracy, its institutions and values.” It’s not clear what ‘ideology’ means in the definition, but the government’s intention to limit further our right to protest is clear. However, the examples that most of us see where parliamentary democracy is overturned is in the work and influence of lobbyists. Look no further than the shady goings on at 55 Tufton Street. The right-wing ideologues in that building are doing much more to undermine democratic processes than people who take to the streets in support of a cause.
The blatant lies of fossil fuel executives, and the undermining of democratic decision making by, amongst others, highly partisan lobbyists, lend ever more credence to XR’s demand for a citizens’ assembly. The only way anyone can say something is what people want is if people are consulted. As part of the Insure Our Future action, the UK’s first Insurance Assembly was held last week. It is being hailed as a success, thanks to the turnout of insurance industry professionals, both in person and online.
This groundbreaking new event held space for creative dialogue, demonstrating the power of deliberative democracy to those in positions of power. It marks significant steps towards shaping a future that includes radical shifts away from ‘business as usual’, and towards a shared vision of hope, interaction and the power of assemblies. It marks a significant moment in the Assembly Escalation Campaign!

While politicians and fossil fuel industry executives are busy doing not nearly enough to avert the climate and ecological crisis, climate activists are busy doing things, week in and week out. On Saturday, XR WAB were among those who took part in a Mothers* Rebellion action in Guildford High Street.
Another brilliant climate action was done last week by the Climate Choir Movement. Around 150 Climate Choir singers took part in a protest inside and outside Parliament, calling for a rethink on the proposed Rosebank oil project in the North Sea. There’s more information and a great video on the Climate Choir Movement website.
On Monday next week the Cut the Ties campaign resumes with action in London, while on Thursday of the same week we will make our views on private jets and Farnborough Airport expansion felt at the Farnborough Aerodrome Consultative Committee meeting.
To know more about actions, please join Telegram if you have not already done so. That’s the forum for ongoing communications on a day-to-day basis. If you have questions about any of the information in the newsletter, please email xrwaverley@gmail.com.
________________________________________
MEETING THIS WEEK via Zoom – WEDNESDAY 13th MARCH
The meeting is from 7.30pm to 9.00pm. If you are joining one of our meetings for the first time, please join at 7.15pm and we can explain a little about our group and how we run meetings.
Contact us for Zoom meeting details.
We’ll be looking forward to upcoming actions (see below), how we can participate, and the plans we need to make for them. Be a part of this local, democratic process.
________________________________________
MONDAY 18th MARCH – CUT THE TIES TO FOSSIL FUELS ~ ACTION CALLOUT

Cut The Ties is an excellent campaign targeted at companies who, through their business ventures, enable the fossil fuel companies to do their work. This action is in London.
Meeting point – Hyde Park, London – https://w3w.co/comet.sofa.owls – Mon 18th March at 8.00am
Join us in support as we expose the lies and corruption of some of the most influential people in the UK.
At 8.20am we will move to another location for a rally to disrupt those complicit and shine a light on the web of dark money.
Bring flags and drums as we REBEL FOR TRUTH and take our message to the doors of climate criminals and enablers.
Dress code: black & white
________________________________________
THURSDAY 21st MARCH – BANNER HOLDERS NEEDED at FACC
Meeting Thursday 21st March from 1.15 – 2pm.
The Farnborough Aerodrome Consultative Committee (FACC) is holding another meeting at Hart District Council Offices, Harlington Way, Fleet, GU51 9SB in an attempt to continue with business as usual at the airport. XR WAB will be there to remind Macquarie and the committee of our dramatic airport march and rally in January.
We will again be demanding that criminally wasteful executive jet flights should be banned from Farnborough.
Bring your No Flying placards and banners, or carry a flag to keep up the pressure. Tell your friends. Residents are still vary angry about the threat of flight number expansion.
If you wish to also attend the meeting to witness the biased way that it is conducted, registration is required.
Please let us know if you are available to attend.
________________________________________
SATURDAY 6th APRIL – GODALMING SPRING FESTIVAL

We plan to have a stall at this event. Typically, we get quite a bit of interest at the various fairs and festivals we attend. We can only do this if we have enough people to help set up, do a shift at some point in the day, and help clear up at the end. It’s a great way to have a conversation with people about the climate crisis, and we’ll use our ‘climate worry chart’ and strategies to draw people’s interest.
If you can help out please email xrwaverley@gmail.com
________________________________________
20th APRIL – FUNERAL FOR NATURE IN BATH
This is advanced notice of the Funeral for Nature that our friends in bath will host. Please put the date in your diary. More details to follow. In the meantime, you can go to this website for more information.
________________________________________
PLAN Z FILM – CROWDFUND APPEAL

This is an excellent project by Louisa Jones (part of XR WAB from the start) and Vladimir Morozov, who have made a short film, Plan Z: from lab coats to handcuffs, about scientists taking direct action. It’s been over a year in the making and it’s now in the final stages. To get the film and its message to the widest possible audience, the filmmakers have set up a crowdfund campaign to help cover expenses and then distribute the finished film as widely as possible.
For more information and to make a contribution, go to their website.
________________________________________
WAB REBEL RHYTHMS – our amazing Samba band!
If you want to know what’s going on with WAB Rebel Rhythms or you want to join, go to the following webpage or email xrwaverley@gmail.com.
The band practices take place on the second Monday of the month from 6.30pm to 8.30pm at Milford Cricket Club, Milford Heath Road, Milford GU8 5BP.
What3words: https://w3w.co/pills.dimes.disco
________________________________________
What’s on at the Climate Emergency Centres
To find out what’s happening at What Next? in Waverley, use this link.
To find out what’s happening at Zero in Guildford, use this link.