Infinite hope
April 29, 2024
It’s tough being a climate activist. You know the science about climate chaos and environmental breakdown. You know you are right to fight for climate justice. And yet, at times, the progress seems slow. It seems unintelligible that other people don’t get it. It seems even harder to believe that politicians don’t take the action needed, and that the fossil fuel industry is committed as ever to maximising profits from extracting, selling and burning fossil fuels.
Hope for the other world we know is possible seems a long way away.
We are not alone in moments of despair. Others have trodden this path and they have prevailed. Martin Luther King, in 1968, famously said that We must accept finite disappointment, but never lose infinite hope.
That’s a great message for us too – to have infinite hope.
With spring well and truly with us, and with birds flitting about our gardens, nesting, and cheering us with their morning song, Emily Dickinson’s poem ‘Hope’ is worth bringing to mind:
Hope is the thing with feathers
That perches in the soul,
And sings the tune–without the words,
And never stops at all,
And sweetest in the gale is heard;
And sore must be the storm
That could abash the little bird
That kept so many warm.
I’ve heard it in the chillest land,
And on the strangest sea;
Yet, never, in extremity,
It asked a crumb of me.
Nature has an incredible ability to recover, and spring is the most emblematic time of that recovery. When it’s hard to see the progress we are making, it’s important to look for those signs that things can change. This will only happen through the actions that people take, like Trudi Warner and Dr Sarah Benn.
These two brave women have been in the news for the consequences of peacefully standing holding a sign. One of them has avoided prison while the other has been further punished for having gone to prison for fighting for climate justice.
Retired GP Dr Sarah Benn had stood on a grass verge in front of an oil terminal in 2022 holding a sign, and was sentenced to 32 days imprisonment for breaching a civil injunction. She reported this to the General Medical Council (GMC). Nobody had complained about her work or medical competence. Dr Benn has had her GMC registration suspended for three months with the tribunal claiming, without evidence, that “the overwhelming majority of the public would not condone breaking the law in the repeated way in which Dr Benn did, especially given the impact, on the final occasion, to the wider public resources involved”. Dr Emma Runswick, British Medical Association deputy chair of council, had said there was “no possible public or patient interest for a tribunal where potential sanctions included the removal of a doctor’s licence in these circumstances”.

Retired social worker Trudi Warner stood outside Inner London Crown Court holding a sign saying: “JURORS YOU HAVE AN ABSOLUTE RIGHT TO ACQUIT A DEFENDANT ACCORDING TO YOUR CONSCIENCE”. She was reacting to the actions of Judge Silas Read who had sent defendants to prison for contempt because they had mentioned climate change or home insulation to the jury. He has more recently threatened a jury with criminal prosecution if they followed their conscience. Trudi was arrested on Read’s instruction and referred to the solicitor general, a Tory MP, for potential prosecution for contempt, causing her months of stress. In an outstanding display of people power, hundreds of people in total sat outside every crown court in England and Wales with similar signs, challenging the authorities to prosecute them also. When the government law officers’ submission, which must have taken hundreds of hours’ work to prepare, was put to the High Court it was quickly trashed by Justice Saini. He called it “fanciful” and said “These submissions significantly mischaracterise the evidence.”
This attempt to suppress protest and the independence of juries, known as jury equity, has spectacularly backfired, with worldwide publicity and has raised awareness of jurors’ rights that have existed for centuries.
Trudi Warner’s actions not only highlight the importance of the rights of jurors. They remind us of the importance of XR’s third demand, We demand a culture of participation, fairness and transparency. The Government must create and be led by a Citizens’ Assembly on Climate and Ecological Justice. Only the common sense of ordinary people will help us navigate the challenging decisions ahead. Citizens’ assemblies function in a quite similar way to juries. During court cases, members of the public are the decision makers, drawing on the evidence of experts. It’s the same with citizens’ assemblies, where non-experts learn the facts from experts and then evaluate those facts to determine the right action to take. In XR, it’s climate justice we are fighting for, so we stand in solidarity with jurors and their right to acquit a defendant according to their conscience.
Progress in tackling climate chaos is slow, but our hope is infinite. Take time to be proud of the part you play and the action you take.
________________________________________
MEETING THIS WEEK
WEDNESDAY 1st MAY 2024 – Zoom meeting at 7.30pm
The meeting will open at 7.15 so please join then if this is your first time at a meeting.
Join Zoom Meeting – Contact us for details
We’ll be planning our Farnham Sustainability Fair presence, and planning our contribution to ‘Restore Nature Now’.
If you have recently joined XR, we very much look forward to welcoming you.
________________________________________
SATURDAY MAY 18th – SURFERS AGAINST SEWAGE PADDLE-OUT
Surfers Against Sewage is a great organisation with clear goals on water quality, plastics pollution, ocean recovery, and the ocean and climate emergency.
On 18th May they are organising a Paddle Out Protest against sewage dumping at different coast and river sites. Everyone is welcome. We are looking at the possibility of joining in with something in Guildford. With the debacle over Thames Water and a general election on the horizon, this is just the right time to make our views known.
More details to follow.
________________________________________
SUNDAY 19th MAY – FARNHAM SUSTAINABILITY FESTIVAL
We have a stall at this event, which takes place in Gostrey Meadow from 11am to 4pm. Rebel Rhythms will be playing. This is a great opportunity for us to promote our events, and especially to explain to people the big event we have in London on 22nd June.
If you are new to our group, helping out at a stall is an excellent way to be a part of our community.
________________________________________
SATURDAY 22nd JUNE – LONDON ACTION – RESTORE NATURE NOW

Nature Needs You!
This action is taking shape. To know what’s planned, go to the XRUK website. early notification of an action on 22nd June.
Rivers choking on pollution, precious woodlands destroyed, seas overfished & peat bogs burned. Nature in the UK is being assaulted.
Last year XRUK created The Big One, where we invited other organisations, charities and groups to demand government action on the climate and ecological nature. On June 22 we return to London, this time, side by side with dozens of organisations and thousands of people from across the country to demand action in a truly co-created action.
We will be taking part as a local group. People are also need for various roles, including for outreach and as a steward.
We are all crew! Please not only take part, but also take a role, and help to make the day a huge success.
________________________________________
WAB REBEL RHYTHMS – our amazing Samba band!
If you want to know what’s going on with WAB Rebel Rhythms or you want to join, go to the following webpage or email xrwaverley@gmail.com.
The band practices take place on the second Monday of the month from 6.30pm to 8.30pm at Milford Cricket Club, Milford Heath Road, Milford GU8 5BP.
What3words: https://w3w.co/pills.dimes.disco
________________________________________
What’s on at the Climate Emergency Centres
To find out what’s happening at What Next? in Waverley, use this link.
Zero is now in new premises at the top of Guildford High Street – to find out more, use this link.