Non-violent protest vs gangland thuggery
March 03, 2025
To be honest, we’d all rather not be climate activists. It’s not because we don’t have other things to do with our lives that we take action. We’d rather a world where there was no climate breakdown, no environmental destruction. It’s because it’s necessary that we are activists. What’s great is that there are many ways to protest so people can take action in the ways that suit them best, or fits with the skills they have or want to develop. An excellent example is the Climate Choir.

On Saturday around 200 singers from the Climate Choir, with activists from the campaign group Wild Card, did an excellent flash mob performance in four-part harmony as the congregation was amassing for evensong. Their song and banners carried the message to the Church of England to rewild 30% of the 105,000 acres of land they own. The action proclaimed what has been well understood for centuries and well before Christopher Wren laid the first stone of the cathedral: “Let the water teem with an abundance of living creatures, and on the earth let birds fly beneath the dome of the sky”. Their message was directed at the Church for good reason.
Think of land owned by the Church of England and you might picture a small rural churchyard filled with wildflowers. But this is just the tip of the iceberg. In reality, the Church of England is one of the top ten landowners in the country. Whilst most churchyards are lovingly tended for nature’s benefit by local congregations, half the Church’s land is managed by an investment body, the Church Commissioners. Most of this land is in a dire ecological state with just 4% tree coverage. In addition, less than half of the 2,000 acres of sites of special scientific interest they own are in a favourable condition. Largely used for intensive farming, only 3% of the land is wooded, compared with the average of 10% across the country, itself a far too low proportion of woodland. This makes it the lowest tree coverage of England’s top ten institutional landowners.
XR WAB may not have had a big presence at this action, but there was at least one of our rebels there on Saturday. The Climate Choir comprises 19 local choirs. If you are inspired to join the Climate Choir, there is a group in Guildford. You can contact them by emailing guildford@climatechoirmovement.org.
While the Climate Choir demonstrated the beauty and creativity of non-violent action, we saw the opposite play out before the media in the Oval Office on Friday. That, of course, was not a climate issue, but it signals the way business is being done by Trump and his cronies. It’s tempting to keep saying that we live in strange times, but that isn’t actually the case. These are predictable, not strange times. Trump’s behaviour, and that of Orban, Putin, Milei and any number of other far-right leaders brings to mind a gangland approach to creating ‘stability’. Quite simply, extort payments from countries in return for protection. Zelenskyy will certainly have felt he was a victim of that sort of a racket.
We should take notice of the behaviour of the Trump administration. Some people may feel a comparison between Trump and Vance, and Hitler and Himmler stretches credulity. Keep an eye on it, Vance has license to say whatever he wants and will do Trump’s bidding for him. In Germany in the 1930s, Hitler courted big businesses to fund his party. He told the captains of industry that “private enterprise cannot be maintained in a democracy.” He also said that he would eliminate trade unions and communists. It’s beginning to sound familiar, isn’t it?
In the meantime, oil and gas companies have ditched their former commitments to sustainable energy. ‘Drill, baby. Drill’ is the new mantra. This isn’t because it’s good for people, it’s because it’s good for the world’s wealthiest capitalists.
The forces against us are formidable. The efforts of European leaders to stand up for some form of democracy is a small comfort, but they don’t yet know how to deal with the massively accelerating change of direction that Trump has precipitated. Starmer’s trip to the White House had the chilling feeling of a Faustian pact. Starmer, like Faust, selling his soul (and a state visit to the UK) to the devil. The story ends badly. Quite simply, he doesn’t get his soul back and is condemned to hell.
The continuing challenge for us and other activities is to know how and when to respond. Firstly, keep doing what we are doing. Take part in actions such as those organised by Climate Choir. Go on XR actions. Join other environmental groups. Join other progressive protest groups. Challenge the views of others when they talk nonsense.
There’s a useful explanation about the difference between ‘not being a racist’ and being an ‘anti-racist’. Anti-racism is not the opposite of racism. Not being a racist is seeing people and treating people as equal, no matter what their background is. You can not be a racist, but that doesn’t mean you will stand up against racism, which is what anti-racists do. Whether it’s in a family conversation or by demonstrating on the streets, anti-racists challenge the views of racists.
As climate activities we need to be the same. We won’t get the change we need just by living our lives in a climate friendly, sustainable way. Like anti-racists, we need to challenge the views and actions of others at every opportunity, whether in a family conversation or by demonstrating on the streets. It’s the only way to be!
________________________________________
MEETINGS THIS SPRING
Please note some changes to the meetings this month as follows:
5th March – we are not meeting this week as there is an event at the University for the Creative Arts called ‘From Fossil Fuels to Farnborough Airport’. Quite a number of people from XR WAB are going, so join in. It’s a highly pertinent topic for us. See details below.
12 the March – we will meet via Zoom, in place of the meeting we were due to have on the 5th.
19th March – in person in Godalming
We very much look forward to seeing as many people as possible at these meetings.
________________________________________
TUESDAY 4th MARCH – Stop fossil fuel giants locking in gas use – rally to support Andrew Boswell’s court appeal
If you are not already going to this action, you’ll need to get you skates on as it’s today!
Last July, Andrew Boswell took the government to court over the Secretary of State’s decision to consent to Net Zero Teesside Power (gas power with carbon capture and storage) despite the fact that the total emissions from the development would be totally incompatible with meeting the government’s emissions reduction targets.
Andrew lost his case in July, but has been given leave to appeal as he has several clearly legally arguable grounds, and the appeal is scheduled for 4th and 5th March. We are seeking to build a huge rally outside the court on 4th March, to support Andrew and show the government that we reject policies that enable fossil fuel giants and the locking in of fossil fuel dependency in our energy system as we race towards climate catastrophe.
To support Andrew, there will be a rally outside the Royal Court of Justice from 12.30.
Speakers include: Professor Paul Behrens, Oxford Martin School Catherine Green, HyNot (campaign against HyNet blue hydrogen CCS in North West) Carys Boughton, Fossil Free Campaigner, Platform UK Brian Barker, Climate Genocide Act Now (CGAN) management team, CGAN and Defend Our Juries Ellen Robottom, Campaign Against Climate Change Trade Union Group Claire James, Campaign Against Climate Change Jessica Townsend, MP Watch Jonathon Porritt, founder Forum for the Future Simon Oldridge, Zero Hour, Climate and Nature bill campaign Simon Pirani, Energy researcher, honorary professor, University of Durham Andrew Boswell, Climate Emergency Planning and Policy.
You can find more information about the court case and the action here.
________________________________________
WEDNESDAY 5the MARCH – From Fossil Fuels to Farnborough Airport
In place of our planned meeting, we suggest people go to this event hosted by Waverley Liberal Democrats and The University for the Creative Arts. They are allies of ours in opposing Farnborough Airport expansion and the Liberal Democrat leader of Waverley Borough Council, Paul Follows, was at our most recent protest at the airport, as was the council’s portfolio holder for Environment & Sustainability, Steve Williams.
The organisers have invited The Guardian’s Energy Correspondent, Jillian Ambrose, to give an exclusive talk on the national and local issues holding back a more sustainable future. Jillian will cover everything from the future of green energy to developments at Farnborough Airport. There is also a question and answer element. You can post your question in advance via the event booking site. Tickets (£10) should be booked in advance.
The event starts at 6.30pm.
________________________________________
WAB REBEL RHYTHMS – our amazing Samba band!
We would love to have more players in the Samba band. Please get in touch to join in. You can find out more at the following webpage or email xrwaverley@gmail.com.
The band practices take place on the second Monday of the month from 6.30pm to 8.30pm at Milford Cricket Club, Milford Heath Road, Milford GU8 5BP.
What3words: https://w3w.co/pills.dimes.disco
________________________________________
What’s on at the Climate Emergency Centres
To find out what’s happening at What Next? in Waverley, use this link.
Zero is now in new premises at the top of Guildford High Street – to find out more, use this link.