The Brain Drain

We’re keeping up our focus on Farnborough Airport. A group of XR WAB rebels were there on Sunday to make sure the message about private jets seeps into the consciousness of local people, and to keep reminding the airport that we are not letting them off the hook. Below is a reminder of the actions you can take.

The other thing to know is that we are having an in-person meeting in Farnham on Wednesday evening this week – details below. While we do talk about actions past and present at these meetings, we focus mainly on these being social occasions. If you have never been to one of our meetings before, this is a great one to come to.

While we have a slower pace regarding actions this month, there is much to get our heads around in the completely crazy world we live in. One of the concerns some people had about a Labour government was that there would be a ‘brain drain’ as people left the country to work elsewhere. By ‘people’, presumably that’s scientists, entrepreneurs, business leaders etc. In the world of politics, there evidently wasn’t much brain to drain in the first place. The Labour party is as devoid of smart ideas as the Tories were. We are in a race to the bottom of the climate, migration and civil liberties barrels.

On civil liberties and the right to protest, the government is making such a hash of it, it would be funny if it weren’t so serious. Proscribing Palestine Action was a mistake and Defend Our Juries have brilliantly taken the argument to the government through the non-violent actions taken. These have resulted in the most perverse situation where to date over 2000 people have been arrested for sitting on the ground holding a placard declaring opposition to genocide and supporting Palestine Action. 

Let’s be clear: the government proscribed Palestine Action; the police choose to arrest people for sitting with a placard. And very importantly, everyone who sits with a placard is prepared to be arrested.

If you were smart and you were concerned about the impact that having to arrest so many people repeatedly for sitting with a placard was having on police resources, you’d surely ask yourself some questions. For example, ‘did we get this one wrong?’ ‘Is it necessary to arrest people for sitting with a placard? Do the protestors pose a risk to society?’

If you are not smart, and you are a quasi-authoritarian government masquerading as a progressive one, you double down. Someone with limited thinking power came up with a great idea, ‘I’ve got it, let’s make it illegal to protest repeatedly about the same issue in the same place, and arrest people who do. And let’s say it’s to protect local people from…er…bad things.’

Clearly, the big idea is to put the threat of arrest on people who have declared, before they sit with a placard, that they are prepared to be arrested. You see, no brain to drain.

Of course, this government, like the previous one, has used a single protest that it doesn’t like to extend its and the police’s authoritarian powers to silence protesters, all the while declaring that they uphold the right to protest. They are not to be trusted. We live in times where the far-right are, without actually having much official power, driving the narrative. The political conference season so far is an anti-migrant fest to rival anything seen prior to the Brexit vote. The only number anyone talks about is how many non-British people they will remove from the country. It’s like an auction of promises and the numbers keep rising. 

Back to aviation, where the government is equally devoid of smart thinking. It has created a Sustainable Aviation Fuel (SAF) Mandate in order to decarbonise flying. It seems to have swallowed the line that SAF is what it says it is, sustainable. Right now, the scientific consensus says it isn’t. 

Firstly, most climate activists would say, quite reasonably, that you can’t burn your way out of a climate emergency. That really is how we got here in the first place. That’s a simple principle, even if you claim that the CO2 you are emitting is carbon neutral because it is plant based. It takes a lot of resources to create SAF so it isn’t carbon-neutral in its lifecycle. And you are still emitting carbon and other tailpipe substances into the high atmosphere where they don’t belong.  

Secondly, it would require the most colossal land grab to create the amount of SAF needed to get anywhere near to ‘sustainable’ flying. Most SAF is made from some form of crop. Some is made from waste products for which there is a demand from other sectors. One study estimates that to grow enough of the seed crop to make SAF for UK aviation would take up half of the country’s agricultural land. Then replicate that around the world and the problem if clear. Not much brain needed there! Fly and don’t eat. Eat and don’t fly. You choose.

What the government’s promotion of SAFs is all about, along with approving airport expansion, is the flawed pursuit of economic growth, effectively at all costs. People want to fly, and the government doesn’t want to say no to that. So here we are.

In a world where there is not much government brain to drain the message is this – keep flying, fly even more if you want, sustainable aviation is already here and will only get better! 

That’s why we have to keep up our pressure on Farnborough, on aviation, on the climate crisis, and on the threat of a sixth mass extinction.

________________________________________

MEETING THIS WEEK – WEDNESDAY 8th OCTOBER

In Person meeting at The Lost Boy pub in Farnham.

Address: 3 Downing St, Farnham GU9 7NX

Depending on numbers, we will either meet in the front bar, or the upstairs meeting room.

Time: 7.15pm

________________________________________

TAKE ACTION ON FARNBOROUGH AIRPORT: 

Write to your MP, local councillors (many of whom are very opposed to Farnborough’s expansion plans) and other interested organisations and ask them to intervene to prevent the airport using the Environmental Impact Assessment (see details below) as a device to avoid a full examination of the effects of more and larger flights at weekends over the wider 15 mile radius area. Please do this especially if you live in Rushmoor Borough Council and/or Alex Baker is your MP. She is an important decision maker.

In your letter, you may want to refer to the following:

  1. The fact that the geographic area is too small.
  2. That the airport is attempting to avoid a public consultation.
  3. Expansion of flights runs in contradiction to local authorities’ declarations of a climate emergency.
  4. Much expansion is planned on weekends when flights are made for leisure, not business. The airport licence is only for business use.
  5. The existence of a nature reserve under the flight path.

Another action to take is to join rebels outside the airport. We intend to do this frequently, to keep the issue in the minds of the public. It’s amazing how many people drive past the airport entrance on a weekend and see our presence. Most acknowledge us positively. Next date to be confirmed.

Please also put Thursday 20th November in your diary for a demonstration at the Farnborough Aerodrome Consultative Committee meeting.

________________________________________

WAB REBEL RHYTHMS – our amazing Samba band!

We would love to have more players in the Samba band. Please get in touch to join in. You can find out more at the following webpage or email xrwaverley@gmail.com.  

The band practices take place on the second Monday of the month from 6.30pm to 8.30pm at Milford Cricket Club, Milford Heath Road, Milford GU8 5BP. Practices also take place occasionally on weekends.

What3words: https://w3w.co/pills.dimes.disco

________________________________________

What’s on at the Climate Emergency Centres

To find out what’s happening at What Next? in Waverley, use this link.To find out what’s going on at Zero Carbon Guildford, use this link.