XR Godalming Update 19th May
May 19, 2020

Another week has passed and we are still in lockdown. While the situation has eased a little, government guidance has caused confusion. The stay alert message is unclear. Rather perversely, you can’t visit a relative in their home, but you can go into someone’s house if you want to buy it. And as we emerge from lockdown, Extinction Rebellion is not immune to indecisiveness or lack of clarity. In our own group we have debated how and when we should pick up actions. Nationally, local groups have responded differently, for example, to last weekend’s ‘reclaim the streets’ bike ride. More on that later. For XR, and for local groups, there is no one correct or incorrect decision, and it’s right that groups use their own democratic processes to make decisions. What we do all remain committed to, and which drives our sense of purpose and binds us in thought and deed, is that we must tackle the climate emergency.
While we plan our next steps, we will be mindful of how others plan theirs. The Guardian has a good article that sets out the challenges we may face, as the old order will fight back to retain the status quo. The authors believe that ‘the old order – that some are already writing eulogies for – will surge back rather than retreating’. They conclude: History shows us that whatever horrors a crisis exposes, they can be covered up in the shattered aftermath. Yes, we must imagine the new world that needs to come out of this crisis: but it will not come to pass without a fight.
ACTIONS YOU CAN TAKE NOW
1. RESPONSE TO WAVERLEY BOROUGH COUNCIL
Here’s a request from Chris for something in the pipeline.
Waverley Borough Council has asked us for feedback on the “Council’s Climate Emergency Action Plan”. We’re pleased that the Council is committed to a robust and measureable plan and this is our opportunity to comment on the detail before it’s passed through the system. It would be really good to make use of the diverse knowledge and expertise we have in the group so that we can give some useful input. The document containing the plan is divided up into a number of topic areas like transport, food production, finance, education and housing/buildings. If you’d like to be part of this, whether from general interest or because you have an interest or knowledge in a specific policy area, then please let us know by putting a message in the Telegram general chat group or by sending an email to xrgodalming@gmail.com. Mark your email Waverley Climate Emergency Plan for the attention of Joyce (Joyce is our XR Godalming link with Waverley). We’ll then create a forum so that everyone interested can see the document and submit comments which we can compile together in a report by the end of June.
2. DUNSFOLD DRILLING
A number of people have posted information on Telegram about the fact that planners have backed UK Oil and Gas (UKOG) plans for drilling at Dunsfold. Kirsty has pointed out that this does not yet have planning permission. It goes to committee this week on Thursday 21 May at 10.30. Keep a look out on the group chat on Telegram. Kirsty will post the link so you can attend the meeting. It would be great to have a strong turnout to put pressure on councillors. Equally, this is an issue to write to Jeremy Hunt about. Carol says he is campaigning against UKOG’s plans. Why not give him a shed load of emails in support of that endeavour?
TO ACT, OR NOT TO ACT (with a bit of reference to what’s been in the news, and to recent meetings)
Among XR groups there has not been a consensus on whether to take action on the streets (see above). Saturday and Sunday were planned as days of action to reclaim the streets. At our group meeting on Wednesday 13 May we discussed whether we should take part in this action. We decided not to. Some groups across the country, for example in Bristol, also chose not to act on this occasion. They had intended to, but pressure from their members resulted in a change of plan. Other groups, such as in Exeter and Peterborough, did go ahead. There’s a short video clip on YouTube of the Exeter event. From the media reports available, which are mostly in regional outlets, press coverage has been fairly neutral. Given the antagonism XR can face, and the sensitivity of the current situation, that’s probably quite a positive outcome.
Considering when and how to take direct action again was a theme of the third Think Tank meeting on Monday 18 May. Another consideration at the Think Tank was what we will do with the research we have completed. We agreed we should summarise what we have found so far. Having done that, we will be able to disseminate those findings to the rest of the group, and to other interested groups/the SE region.
Some of the Think Tank research will be used to make adjustments to forthcoming Heading for Extinction presentations. Having completed research, any alterations to the presentation will be underpinned by evidence and secure references.
We agreed to pursue further our understanding of land use, farming, and food production and distribution. There are a number of local people who we believe will be able to present on these subjects, so a series of talks will be planned. As with other talks, these also provide an opportunity to extend invitations outside the group and attract new people to XR.
At the Think Tank we discussed the notion that XR actions and demands are beyond politics. We considered whether this is ever really possible, and agreed that they should certainly be beyond party politics. But, XR’s demand for a citizens’ assembly is in itself a demand for a specific form of political intervention. We also agreed that our message should be about looking forward, and challenging heavily the notion that by seeking action on the climate emergency we want to turn the clock back. We don’t want to go back to some idealised past age, we want a transformed future.
At last week’s meeting, we discussed taking action to hold Surrey County Council to account for spending the money they have been allocated by central government to improve pedestrian and cycle routes. We haven’t decided the actions yet, but the toolkit created off the back of the SPAN action may prove useful.
MATT’S COLUMN
Last week we shared one of the fortnightly columns that Matt writes for the Farnham Herald. Here is the most recent article, on the impact of HS2:
Thanks to the Wildlife and Countryside Act of 1981, cutting trees and hedges in summer can carry a heavy penalty if the culprit is found to be knowingly disturbing nesting birds. Regrettably, it seldom seems to be enforced.
One would hope a country ranked among the most nature-depleted on Earth might try rather harder to improve its standing but, against a backdrop of casual wildlife and habitat degradation, we now bear witness to “the mad vanity project of the HS2 train”, as Simon Barnes refers to it in his latest book. The greatest act of ecological vandalism of the modern age would be just as apt a description, with hundreds of precious tracts of ancient woodland and other wildlife habitats already being sliced up or destroyed entirely. There’s good reason why a host of conservation organisations – from the RSPB to the Woodland Trust – are up in arms. We might just as well let loose an axe-wielding mob in the Tate; the damage is just as irreversible.
HS2’s supporters cry hypocrisy at environmentalists campaigning against a railway line but, even if one chooses to ignore the aforementioned damage, it’s clear the project is a Trojan Horse; an overpriced (estimated £106bn) and carbon-intensive taxi service to two airports – Birmingham and Manchester – both, coincidentally, planning to expand. Not only will the development and running of the line produce 1.5 million tonnes of CO2, it will also make it even easier for people to fly, at a time when we ought to be doing the opposite.
Seven million trees will allegedly be planted to mitigate for the carving up of ancient woodlands, but thousands of the tiny saplings have already died after two of the hottest summers on record. Oliver Rackham must be turning in his grave… “10,000 oaks of 100 years old are not a substitute for one 500 year old oak”.
DE-ESCALATION TRAINING
A reminder of the de-escalation training that Jenny has organised for Saturday 23 May, from 10.30am to 1.00pm. Jenny has been at pains to point out on Telegram that this is still going ahead. If you have received a cancellation notice, ignore it. Jenny will send further details.
WEBSITE DEVELOPMENT
Tim and Basil’s development of the XR Godalming website is coming along. Please take a look at xrgodalming.org. At the meeting on Wednesday we discussed ideas for content. Please contact Tim or Basil if you have any thoughts, or if you want to be involved in the project.
PEOPLE’S ASSEMBLY NOTES FROM 6TH MAY
As previously mentioned some notes were written up from the PA on 6th May in which we discussed messaging and tactics for the post-covid world. You’re welcome to let us know any further thoughts you have on the subject matter or join the Think Tank group to explore such issues in more depth.
THIS WEEK’S MEETING
This Wednesday (20 May) we have another open mic session, organised by Louisa. The last one was excellent, so do come along and either contribute, or sit back and appreciate the eclectic mix of entertainment.
As always at present, the session will be on zoom. Please contact us for details.
The session starts at 7.30pm
FORTHCOMING EVENTS
Saturday May 23, online de-escalation training session (see above).
Wednesday 27 May, regular Wednesday meeting.
Book club – Duncan is going to send the next set of reading for the book club via Telegram, and we’ll sort out a date for the next session.
Heading for Extinction talk. We are looking at doing a Zoom version of the H4E talk, with some adjustment to the content in light of the coronavirus crisis. A date has yet to be firmed up, but likely to be in the first half of June.
Look forward to seeing you on Wednesday or soon.
With hope and determination.
XR Godalming