Watching COP26 fail, round-up 9th November
November 09, 2021
“Do you believe in leaders or in us?” The question was posed on Saturday by a Minga Indigena activist said protesting in Glasgow. Minga Indigena is a collective of groups and communities from indigenous nations throughout the American continent. They continued, “just as our ancestors defended the lands, we will continue”. They have good reason to. According to the United Nations, indigenous people are among the first to face the direct impacts of global warming on the ecosystems or landscapes they inhabit, owing to their dependence upon, and close relationship with, the environment and its resources. How fitting, therefore, that among so many other people who protested in one form or another on the global day of action on Saturday, the voice of indigenous people was heard.

Saturday was a monumental day for too many reasons to list! It was a day of action, of hope, of collaboration and of commitment. We will all no doubt turn to and remember our favourite or most notable moments. Many excellent ones have been shared on Telegram. What’s so impressive is that so many people, and groups of people came together over their concern for the climate and ecological crisis, and that they did so with a positive frame of mind as people who are prepared to do something.



The day of action was orchestrated by the COP26 coalition, and coalition was a strong theme of the day. Whether in Glasgow, or in smaller towns such as Aldershot and Godalming, people from a variety of different backgrounds, causes and movements came together to express their concern for the planet, and their desire for immediate action. In Aldershot, XR, Friends of the Earth, Labour and the Liberal Democrats marched together. On their way they managed a quick stop-off at Farnborough Airport to block one of the gates; excellent activism. In Godalming, XR rebels were on the High Street alongside What Next? and Compass. Shirley and David in particular, on behalf of What Next?, oversaw a great day of eco-theatre, talks, children’s story telling and music to bring to people’s attention the crisis we are in. In Glasgow and London, WAB rebels stood shoulder to shoulder with the myriad of people who marched and spoke on Saturday.
Perhaps the day of over 300 marches and demonstrations worldwide is best summed up by Kathy Jetnil-Kijiner, a poet and climate activist from the Marshall Islands. She told the fable of the whale taunting a tiny bird, bragging that it was the biggest and most powerful creature in the sea. But the tiny bird organised a flock of thousands, which drank up the ocean and forced the whale to recognise that smallness is a state of mind.
One of the things you don’t get with people who know what they are talking about, and are serious and passionate about the issues we face, are crass metaphors and idioms that don’t work. In contrast to Kathy Jetnil-Kijiner and many others who spoke on Saturday, Johnson is the master of speaking utter rubbish. At the start of COP26 he suggested that we are at one minute to midnight in our bid to save the planet. He added that we are in a football match where humanity is 5 – 1 down to climate change. Then, after two days of negotiating and the planet still in peril, Johnson declared that humanity has clawed back a goal, possible two. Johnson has never been one for details. What those goals amount to, no one knows. On top of that, we apparently have the chance to take the match to extra time, despite the fact we are at one minute to midnight and extra time would take 30 minutes. No wonder a protester in Glasgow on Saturday held up a banner saying ‘your maths = our death’. Too bloody right! What’s absolutely wrong here, and not nearly enough of the media comment on this, is that the whole premise that we are on an opposing team to climate change is wrong. For this government, everything is binary – us and them. If we really want to use the football match analogy – although in truth, why would we? – but if we did, then in reality, we are the team that created climate change. Johnson just doesn’t seem to get that. We have played on the climate change team, unwittingly or not. Successive governments have been the managers of that team. Banks have been the sponsors of that team. Using a team sports metaphor with its oppositional approach, so typical of government, doesn’t work. We need to work with the planet. What we all know is that we need an approach that centres on collaboration, coalition, consideration. These are the three ‘C’s the government should focus on.
So, metaphors used by the government are poorly expressed, jumbled up, don’t make sense and show a lack of grip of the real problem. But Johnson probably doesn’t plan what he’s going to say, it’s improvised gibberish. You’d have thought, however, that the chair of COP26 would have a team of script-writers on hand to make sure that everything he says is on point. So how does he come up with a motoring idiom to describe the significance of the second week of negotiations? He said that this week the “rubber will hit the road” as negotiators try to hash out a deal on international carbon markets. Does he not realise that 70% of the world’s rubber is synthetic, and is made from crude oil!? Unbelievable! Is he not aware of the degraded rubber and plastic from vehicle tyres that is polluting the oceans? You just can’t make it up.
What is perhaps most surprising is that Johnson missed the opportunity for a choice classical allusion. The Greek work Kairos refers to a time when conditions are right to make a crucial decision. That’s where we are now. We are at that crucial time. This is the decisive moment – this is Kairos. 100,000 protestors in Glasgow know that. Protesters all over the globe know that. So do people whose lives are already catastrophically affected by climate change, in Uganda, Moldova, the Marshall Islands, the Philippines, Madagascar, Sri Lanka, Bangladesh, Puerto Rico, Haiti, the Bahamas…
Therefore, we will continue with the spirit of determined optimism, love and rage. We will take these to the next event, the ‘rise and rebel’ post-COP march in London on Saturday 13 November. We will not stop until all people across the planet are safe.