In the wake of COP26
November 15, 2021
Everyone reading this will have doubtless read much already about COP26, its outcomes and what they mean for the future. It’s hard to know what can usefully be added. Some voices that most activists will respect (like Christiana Figueres) tell us that there are positives to hold onto and work with. Many others point to the failures to nail down commitments to ending our dependency on fossil fuels and giving proper financial aid and just reparation to nations on the front-line of the climate crisis, (not to mention emissions targets which actually add up to staying below 1.5) as evidence of the apparent incapacity of political leaders to do what’s actually necessary.

As a moment in consciousness, the evidence of failure, albeit expected, is not easy to be with; the bitter taste made worse by the the efforts of our ridiculous ‘government’ to spin the outcome as a wild success. Still, at least there is more clarity. The voices of activists and those in the media and politics who are awake may differ regarding whether they think the outcomes represent devastating failure or merely a serious disappointment, but they are agreed on one one thing: there is nothing else to be done but keep on trying to bring about change.
How we do this, how we keep on seeking ways to promote the changes which are necessary and to look for the social tipping points which can bring success, by aligning many more people with our cause, will be a question for much discussion, both inside and outside XR. For all its shortcomings, the fact that COP is over for another year, shifts the context; we need to consider what is the best strategy now.
At last week’s meeting we spent some time on that question and at the meetings in the weeks to come we hope to find space and perhaps some fresh ways. of thinking about that together. Something we noted last week was that, despite the fact (as was already becoming clear by then) that COP26 would be a relative failure in terms of actions agreed to, it’s undeniable that over the past few years there has been a massive change in awareness; and that the work we’ve been doing as activists has made a huge contribution to that. To a great extent at least we can maybe put a ’tick’ beside the first XR demand – “Tell the Truth” – despite the ongoing efforts of some to hide or spin its meaning and implications, the truth is out. Now we face the challenge of getting people to act upon it.
It may be worth thinking of this as an issue of psychology, as well as politics. It’s been long understood by many psychologists that understanding or acknowledging a truth is often a necessary step towards action, but it’s not sufficient. We are all aware of people, (or perhaps parts of ourselves), who know undeniable truths, and even exactly what they must do in order to bring about important changes which are crucial to their wellbeing, and yet they don’t do what they must do. Sometimes they finally come to their senses, find courage, and act. Sometimes they leave it too late. Our job now as activists seems to be holding up a mirror, with as much care and effort as we can, which shows people the gap between what they know and what they are doing about it. As angry and distressed as we may feel about what is happening, we need, also, to keep doing that in a way which is loving, to ourselves as well as to others. We often hear, and say, on XR demonstrations, that “Another world in possible” and we must try to convey the truth of that in what we offer.