Democracy and decision making

20.11.21 London. Climate march, from Royal Courts of Justice to Lambeth Bridge, in solidarity with imprisoned Insulate Britain protestors.

“Show me what democracy looks like”

This is one of the chants commonly taken up during protests by XR and others. Protest is a fundamental part of democracy and it has never been more important. As the government work harder on laws to limit protest than they do on those to limit the destruction of nature and the environment it is worth reflecting on why protest, and a healthy democracy, is so important for the challenges ahead.

Extinction Rebellion’s 3rd demand is to “Go Beyond Politics and create and be led by a Citizens’ Assembly on Climate and Ecological Justice”. This demand was one of the more successful in 2019 with the Government setting up a Citizens’ Assembly on Climate Change, though as it was not legally binding it was a largely symbolic exercise.

In a nutshell:

  1. Citizens Assemblies start with a process called sortition that selects a panel that is representative of the population from the public. 
  2. The panel is then presented with facts from subject matter experts for the topic they are tackling and work with those experts to understand the choices available.
  3. The panel deliberate, debate and ultimately vote on a set of recommendations.
  4. The incumbent government implements policies based on, or to meet, those recommendations. 

There are numerous examples of this process working to tackle complex and divisive issues in an open and democratic way. It takes the responsibility away from the politicians who are often paralised by their party line or vested interests, allowing a decision to be made freely by people considering the facts. The UK Climate Assembly recommendations, while non-binding, triggered some interesting responses. Both climate activists and their detractors were unhappy with the proposals being far too weak or far too radical respectively, perhaps this can be read as a good indication that a reasonable balance was struck.

Citizens’ Assemblies are not, however, a panacea to our political woes, there are great examples of them working but it’s not guaranteed. The Irish Citizens Assembly is widely, and rightly, cited as a success for tackling some particularly sensitive issues, however less well known are the recommendations the Assembly made on climate policy. Their proposals, which were considered radical, have mostly failed to gain any traction; the politicians were glad to have the help of the Assembly for issues that were too politically volatile for them to handle, but the Climate Crisis…well now we have GDP to consider.

“This is what democracy looks like”

Within the Waverley and Borders microcosm of the climate movement we have our own decisions to make about how we move forward. We have a sense that we are at a crossroads after COP26 and with many different pulls on our time and attention both as individuals, working groups, the local group and nationally. We are now embarking on a democratic process to work out what we do now. The proposed questions are:

XR WAB exists to raise awareness about and campaign for action on the climate and ecological  crisis. What do we need to do now to bring about necessary changes? Are there any changes which we should make in our strategy and methods? What are the key goals for us as we move forward?

When making decisions at a local level we sometimes use People’s Assemblies (not to be confused with Citizens’ Assemblies). People’s Assemblies are a way of making decisions as a group using a framework that attempts to ensure everyone is included and everyone’s voice is heard. This is achieved using a format with a few basic rules and facilitators to keep the process to those rules.

On 8th December our session will start at 7pm and be finished at 8:45pm and we will be holding a People’s Assembly to discuss the questions above. More details nearer the time but for the process to be successful the group and process will benefit from as broad participation as possible. Whether you’re a regular or occasional attendee your input is important and valuable to the process so please make it if you can. If you’re interested in helping facilitate then please let us know.