A Win For Protest, By Protest
January 18, 2022
On Saturday, Extinction Rebellion joined a coalition of groups protesting against the Police, Crime, Sentencing and Courts (PCSC) Bill, and WAB rebels were out in force. Some joined the Samba band, some joined the women dressed in black and yellow who marched together hand-in-hand, some put their feet on the streets at a protest for the first time, and all added their voices to the demand to Kill the Bill.

The day of protest, which took place in cities across the country, was widely and mostly either sympathetically or neutrally reported in media outlets, such as in The Guardian, Mail Online, Sky News and Evening Standard. The news video clips are worth watching; you may see the occasional rebel you recognise. The comments, such as those by readers of the Mail, are best avoided. They show that there are people who clearly feel no need to protest at anything and don’t understand why other people do. Some people are more outraged by a brief disruption to their daily lives due to protests, than by the daily destruction to life itself by human actions that are destroying the planet.
As of just hours before this post went out, the Lords have voted down amendments to the PCSC Bill, having spent yesterday considering changes including:
- new powers for ministers regarding the definition of serious disruption and the imposition of conditions on public processions under the Public Order Act 1986
- creating new offences of ‘locking on’; obstructing the construction or maintenance of major transport works; and interfering with the use or operation of key national infrastructure, including railways, airports, ports, oil infrastructure and newspaper printing
- increasing penalties for the wilful obstruction of a highway
- new stop and search powers
- the creation of ‘serious disruption prevention orders.
Thanks to the hard work of activists from many groups including XR we can now rest a little easier knowing that some of the worst elements of the bill will never see the light of day again and the rest is going to be exposed to whatever resistance can be mustered while it makes its way back through the commons again.
Governments can do so much more to save the planet, but despite promises made at COP26, ours continues to fall short in that endeavour. That’s not just the view of climate activists, that’s the government’s own view stated in its third Climate Change Risk Assessment which was published yesterday. From a climate activist’s perspective, examples of misdirection and falling short are to be found in how government money is allocated. In 2020/21 the government spent nearly £11 billion on roads. In the current Road Investment Strategy, referred to as RIS2, which runs to 2025, the government plans to spend a further £27.4 billion in order to ‘improve the lives of all’. Policy makers just don’t understand irony!
XR is opposed to RIS2 and has set up Roads Rebellion. XR sets out the case as follows:
We are rebelling against the Government’s Road Building Programme (RIS2 and all other new roads). And the Government’s prioritisation of private vehicles over public transport and active travel investment. Transport is the UK’s largest emitting carbon sector accounting for a third of total UK emissions. It is the only sector where emissions have increased rather than fallen since 1990.
Transport decarbonisation will not be achieved by the current strategy of building more roads and assuming all can have an electric vehicle (EV). Although we need to replace fossil fuel cars with electric ones, even with the most optimistic uptake of EVs the vast majority of mileage over the next ten years will be by fossil fuelled vehicles. Many people cannot afford EVs and simply switching from petrol/diesel cars to EVs is also not desirable for a whole host of other environmental reasons. To meet the fourth, fifth (and possibly sixth) carbon budgets, it will be necessary both to achieve an earlier transition to electric vehicles and to reduce miles driven.
Carbon emissions from building new roads and their subsequent use is not properly accounted for and the environmental impacts are enormous. Producing and leasing more privately owned cars, many of which are SUVs, is not compatible with a safe future. The assumption that everyone can switch to private electric vehicles bakes in more material extraction, destruction of nature and embedded carbon from the production of those vehicles. We want the Government to flip their funding from road building to investment in active travel and public transport.
Saturday 29th January is a day of banner drops to demand that no new roads are built. This is the next action on our agenda – details below. Continuing on the theme of transport, the government also fails to tackle the issue of flying in general, and flights in private jets in particular. We have ongoing actions at Farnborough Airport with the next on Saturday 5th February.
The government’s failure to tackle the climate crisis is seen mostly in the continued funding through incentives, subsidies and tax breaks for the fossil fuel industry. The most recent OECD data suggests that the UK government provides financial support of one form another to the fossil fuel industry in the region of £10 billion per year. It’s therefore right that we therefore demand that this funding ceases, that all new oil and gas exploration is stopped and that we have a just transition to alternative energy. We will keep up the excellent local work we are doing and look forward to taking the campaign back to London in April.