Impossible to Ignore
March 14, 2022
It’s now clear from XR UK what the focus of the April rebellion will be. It is set out in the XR UK website as follows:
In April, we call on everyone to take action and demand an end to the fossil fuel economy, for the UK Government to immediately stop the harm that is happening right now and end fossil fuel investments. We will join with other movements to block oil refineries across the UK until the government comes to the negotiating table, followed by a mass flood of people in London, causing maximum disruption and making meeting the immediate demand politically unavoidable.
Our disruption will not stop until the fossil fuel economy comes to an end.
In the WAB Telegram chat there has been some discussion, and a bit of disquiet about the target for the rebellion given the current oil and gas crisis, compounded as it is by the war in Ukraine. It is going to be extremely important for us to get our argument sorted and clear, as many people will challenge us about the timing. We may be accused of being unsympathetic and people will argue now is not the time, as we need to get over the immediate energy supply crisis first.
The truth is, those arguments are false. Firstly, there are two crises here. The first is the oil and gas supply crisis. The second (which is really the first) is the environmental and climate crisis. The former has some potentially straightforward solutions but may result in short term shortages in energy supply. The longer-term solutions include a massive increase in alternative, sustainable energy. But to be clear, no one needs to die as a result of a temporary energy supply problem. That situation can be managed by an effective government (yes, therein lies a problem!). Those of us old enough to remember the energy crisis of the 1970s know we will survive the problem.
The environmental and climate crisis, on the other hand, poses an existential threat to humans, and to every other living being and plant on the planet. If one of the solutions used to manage the energy supply crisis is further/increased use of UK sourced oil and gas or, as has been suggested, a short-term re-introduction of coal powered electricity, then the second crisis continues to worsen, and we career at ever greater speed beyond the climate tipping point.
One of the great things about XR is the demand for a just transition. That has multiple layers of meaning. In the broadest sense we think of the crisis we face in global terms, so that citizens of the global south stop having their lives devastated by the over-consumption of energy and other resources in the global north. It also means an acknowledgement that potentially, in the transition to renewable energy and more sustainable living, those with the lowest incomes, as nations and as individuals, may be least able to afford those changes. As a result, the gap between nations and individuals who have, and those who have not increases. That problem isn’t one created by climate activists, it’s a failure of our political and economic system. We need to be clear that we want the government not only to stop fossil fuel investment, but we want them to distribute wealth and energy fairly, so that those who are less well off are supported. Windfall taxes on oil and gas companies are an obvious way to do this in the UK. It is the government that stands in the way here, not XR.
Ultimately, in the campaign for climate justice, we were always going to get to a point of escalating crises, because we were already in a crisis. One way or another, something would come along to put more pressure on us as activists, and on the climate crisis. If it were not the war in Ukraine then it would be something else because in the long-term (arguably in the sort-term as well) failure is baked into the system. Burning fossil fuels is killing the planet and the arguments about short- and long-term energy supply have never been more up for grabs than now. It is horrible that a war has brought the debate into a new orbit, but XR is neither capitalising on that, nor showing a lack of sympathy. We were in a crisis and demanded an end to the use of fossil fuels. We are in an even bigger crisis, and we are still demanding an end to the use of fossil fuels. Our argument is constant, relevant and has been consistently truthful.
What’s crucial is that we get huge numbers of people out on the streets for the rebellion from 9th April. That is an over-riding priority. This newsletter is focused on the rebellion and on our actions in the lead up to the rebellion. We have outreach and talks over the coming weeks. Locally, and via XR UK, there is a lot of training. If there is one thing you can do now, it’s to commit time to the rebellion, and encourage everyone you know to do the same. At this rebellion longstanding rebels will step up into mentorship, guiding tactically smart, highly disruptive mass participation action designed to disrupt, engage and recruit new rebels in Central London, with built-in options for level of risk. We’ll be easy to find, easy to join, disruptive and impossible to ignore.