XR Godalming Update 5th May

Another week, another seven days in lockdown. Hopefully everyone is healthy, and their families and friends doing OK. As always, we need to pause to think of those who are negatively affected by the coronavirus crisis. As a community, we should continue to do what we can to support each other, and those around us.

Equally, as we do when we meet, we should take a moment to reflect on why we are a part of Extinction Rebellion, what motivates us to participate and what hopes we have for the future.

On Sunday the prime minister will apparently outline the country’s route out of lockdown. We have spoken a lot within our group about how locally and nationally XR should pick up direct action to avoid a return to business as usual, and keep a focus on the need to tackle the climate emergency. Much of this newsletter relates to moving on…

IN THE NEWS (and in case you missed it on Telegram)

There has been a lot of information shared on various XR chats, and as not everyone is part of all of them, here’s a few most of us will find interesting:

XR’s Surrey Pensions Act Now (SPAN) action has worked hard to convince Surrey County Council to divest its pension investment portfolio from fossil fuels.

Desmogblog has an article about big banks pulling out of oil and gas. The opening is tantalising enough to encourage further reading: ‘The finances of the oil and gas industry are so dismal that the major banks that have funded the money-losing fracking boom are now exploring taking the unusual step of taking over the oil companies that cannot afford to pay back the banks’ loans.’

Pension fund managers take note!

On the same theme, this article starts with the assertion that ‘given the likely duration of our economic woes, this could well be the beginning of the end for the age of oil’. It concludes that ‘it’s time to face the fact that the Covid-19 pandemic is forcing us to leave the fossil fuel era behind us’.

If local government pension fund managers were in any doubt that rebels from SPAN or elsewhere didn’t know what they were talking about, then this article in Bloomberg will make sobering reading for them. Having explored the reasons for Shell’s financial demise and on posing the question about what investors in Shell will do the, ‘their verdict on Thursday, as shares dropped 11% in London, was clear: Sell.’ We would hate to say “I told you so” to Surrey pension fund managers, but really, we told you so!

Maddy Harland’s presentation on permaculture a couple of weeks ago (see last week’s newsletter) prompted many of us to think more about land and farming. This also linked with one of the Think Tank topics. This article explores a link between coronavirus and the British food system. This one by Tim Lang, who is professor of food policy at City university and co-author with Erik Millstone of The Atlas of Food, also explains the problems facing Britain’s food supply chain.

THINK TANK

On Thursday evening we held the second Think Tank session, where our research into the three questions we set ourselves were debated. These are:

Q1. What are the current known links between Covid-19 and climate change? Followed by: what is the best argument to use to get policy makers to see, and act on the connection between Covid-19 and climate change?
Q2. What are the economic arguments that can be used to convince business leaders and politicians to leave fossil fuels in the ground and build a carbon-free economy?
Q3. Do we need to shift our focus, and onto what, to get the public on board? What are the best arguments to use to get the general public to change their behaviour following their experiences in the Covid-19 pandemic?

There was a proposal for a 4th question/issue along the lines of a demand to take oil companies into public ownership. The current crisis and the dire economic situation of the oil companies perhaps presents an opportunity to do that and to bring about a ‘managed death’ of the oil companies. We debated and shared different views about the merits and feasibility of such an approach. The group also noted that coal continues to be used for generating power, particularly in developing countries.

A repeating topic was whether it would be more effective to use messaging which stressed what we shouldn’t do (no more oil/coal) or what we should/could do (investing in green energy, look at nature coming back, ‘another world is possible’). Ideas were debated of using narrative and story to nudge people in the right direction. There was general agreement that we should be ambitious and try to seize the opportunities which this situation presents. There was a suggestion for a social media campaign, either locally or attached to a regional/national campaign, about the positive discoveries from the crisis, while recognising the great suffering and difficulty many face.

We heard about some of the different options for ‘another world’. These include an economic model not based on consumption. This was the donut model as proposed by the economist Kate Raworth which is gaining support and recently taken up by Amsterdam city council for their future planning.

We talked about it being time for XR to adopt a 4th demand about global justice. Everything that has happened with Covid-19 has illuminated the issue of how the least wealthy and powerful are the most vulnerable to a public health emergency.

We noted that question 3 had originally been envisaged to point to a focus on food security and this was linked to land use and land justice. This could be another possible local project with possible links to the land justice movement and Landworkers’ Alliance.

Louisa and Basil have taken on the task of researching the views of people in XR Godalming about question 3. The possibility of a people’s assembly was discussed (see below).

SOUTH EAST ACTIONS CIRCLE (SEAC)

Chris attends SEAC meetings. The group is doing a lot of thinking and talking and planning on how XR can respond most effectively as we emerge from the Covid-19 lockdown. It is considering what the messages are that we want to convey and how best, through actions and other means to get them across. SEAC is also working on being well-prepared. This includes de-escalation training, such as the session planned for Godalming later this month, and some online training on the basics of non-violent direct action. One of the working groups being built cross-region is for Rebel Riders and hopefully our own ‘critical mass’ group will be able to link into that.

WEBSITE DEVELOPMENT

A quick note that Tim and Basil have started to build xrgodalming.org. It would be good to find some more people willing to help build it or help with content. We also need to make some decisions about what we want on the website – suggestions please…

LAST WEEK’S SESSION

Last week we had a lively meeting. We started with a check-in where we shared our experiences of coping with lockdown. These were wide ranging and included:

  • Planting seeds
  • Enjoying bonsai trees
  • Connecting with family members, either those in the house, or via phone and video chats
  • Taking time to note what the natural world is doing, especially the joys of spring and the abundant blossom
  • Making interesting food – nettle and ransom soup was particularly noted
  • Adding structure to the days
  • Working on the allotment
  • Taking time to explore our gardens, including ponds with newts, frogs and toads
  • Surrounding yourself with calm people and baking bread

After check-in we had a presentation by Mags from XR Staines on future democracy. This was an XR presentation called Trust the People. The premise is that the climate crisis is a crisis of democracy. To this end, democracy needs to be re-shaped and the proposed model is through community groups. The current crisis has resulted in a plethora of new local voluntary groups being set up. These groups across the country have filled the void left by government negligence.

We are at a fork in the road. We need to ask how we can sustain community organisation instead of going back to the failed form of business as usual. The argument is that the current crisis has awakened something in people which can be harnessed further. We need to avoid a return to disaster capitalism.

For XR, this means building its own movement around its 3rd demand: a citizen’s assembly. People need to be given responsibility, as this results in responsible action. Examples such as the one in Frome need to be followed, where residents’ groups have been successful in local government.

In XR, a future democracy hub is looking at best practice around the world. XR is not looking for an idealised solution, but for a process that gives people the tools to self-organise. ‘Community transformers’ are at the heart of enabling change and will help groups to step into their radical potential. XR will provide training and peer support.

Mags ended with a quote from Buckminster Fuller:

You never change things by fighting the existing reality.
To change something, build a new model that makes the existing model obsolete.

We are very grateful to Mags for joining us and giving such a thought-provoking presentation. The debate afterwards was energetic.

After the event Mags sent us this follow-up message:

Fab to connect with you all yesterday. It would be wonderful to continue last night’s conversations, you’re very welcome to contact me. If you’d like to join the Community Transformers program please follow this link. This will connect you to the peer support network of other community organisers dedicated to building lasting systemic change. If you’d like to become part of a Hive of 8 other Community Transformers please complete this form. Your Hive would be like your community organising ‘family’ with fortnightly zoom calls to check in and share experiences and tips. We are aiming for Hives to be drawn from the same XR region to build strong region wide connections. Here’s a link to an overview of the project.

THIS WEEK’S MEETING

This week we have a meeting on Wednesday at 7.30pm via Zoom.

This session will run as a people’s assembly with three questions:

1. Do you feel that XR’s demands are still relevant in a post-Covid context? Would you change anything going forwards?

2. What message(s) do you believe XR should prioritise going forwards?

3. What tactics could be used to bring these messages to bear most effectively (while remaining respectful of social distancing for as long as we deem to be necessary)?

These questions link also to the discussion held in the Think Tank.

FORTHCOMING EVENTS

The next Think Tank meeting is on Monday 18 May. Feel free to join.

We have a provisional date for an online de-escalation training session to be run for our group/area on the morning of Saturday May 23. Please save the date if you are interested in joining. More details in due course.

Look forward to seeing you on Wednesday or soon.

With hope and determination.

XR Godalming