A matter of integrity
October 09, 2023
On Wednesday we had a very successful screening of the film My Extinction at Godalming Borough Hall – over 100 people attended. As with so much that we do, it’s hard to know the impact of our actions and events. The film was one to which seasoned rebels will have related. We all have our own ‘my extinction’ story to tell. Hopefully, the film will have inspired others who have not yet done so to step over the threshold into activism. There were certainly good conversations had after the film.
As much as being a good story about one person’s realisation that it’s down to all of us to take action, the film also provides a good insight into the dangerous machinations of the think tanks that operate from 55 Tufton Street. These duplicitous organisations know exactly what they are doing in their manipulation of the truth for the benefit of their political and financial cronies. As if on cue, we recently had one of the most striking examples. On Wednesday 20th September, Sunak announced changes to key measures to achieve net-zero by 2050, including in relation to vehicle electrification and landlords insulating homes. He claimed that this was a proportionate and pragmatic approach that would save families thousands of pounds. On Thursday 21st September Civitas, a thinktank based in 55 Tufton Street, published a pamphlet which reported that the cost of reaching net zero targets would be £4.5 trillion. That’s quite a hike from the Climate Change Commission’s (CCC) estimate of costs of £0.3 trillion once household savings due to the lower cost of renewable energy are accounted for.
How can two organisations come up with such different figures? The answer is motive. The CCC is a statutory body with a responsibility to provide advice to the government and report on progress in achieving, amongst other things, net-zero targets. They have governance to ensure the validity of their advice and reports. Civitas is a climate-sceptic/denying think tank that feels free to publish what it likes, without the need for peer review or any other form of governance. The pamphlet they published was written by Ewen Stewart, who described COP26 in Glasgow as ‘theatre of the absurd’. Stewart does not believe there is a climate emergency, whether caused by human action or not.
So, what did Civitas do to come up with their figures? Incredibly, they ‘confused’ megawatts with megawatt hours, thereby vastly over-estimating, by 10,000 times, the cost of producing electricity via onshore wind farms. To compound the issue further, they ‘confused’ trillions with billions. Sunak claimed that he was being ‘honest’ with the public about the cost of decarbonising our energy and transport. Unsurprisingly, the Civitas report was quickly found to have errors, but not before the right-wing press picked it up and ran stories about the apparent high cost of reaching net-zero, not least for us all, the consumers. For Civitas and Sunak, with the help of their friends in the media, it was a case of ‘job done’.
That’s one of loads of examples that could be cited. If the think tanks at Tufton Street are not peddling misinformation, then the government is more than happy to do so of its own volition. Last week, government ministers claimed that the CCC has said that even in 2050, the UK will need to generate 25% of its electricity using fossil fuels. Remarkably, no one can find that information. The CCC has said fossil-fuel generated electricity may need to be in the mix in 2050, but no-one has said it would be 25%.
Sunak is not being honest with the British public. That’s why we must continue to do what we do. We are not yet at first base with our demands – Tell the Truth! That remains a core aim, along with our other demands and campaigns.
My Extinction is a great motivator for action. Equally, Roger Hallam continues to make amazing arguments for direct action. If you want to know what happens when a journalist who is embedded in the system is unable to relate emotionally to the horrors of human suffering and death that are coming down the track, then listen to the interview between Roger Hallam and Nick Robinson. Hallam is unswerving in his purpose, while Robinson fails to understand what’s going on. He challenges Robinson to consider what he is ‘going to do to have integrity in your life?’ Hallam continues to raise the level of that debate. Robinson’s conclusion shows he really did not get it and summarised the discussion in personal and personality terms. You can find the interview here.
If you have wondered how to get started with direct action, then there is no better time than now! Next week we will be at the Energy Intelligence Forum supporting Fossil-Free London’s ‘Oily Money Out’ campaign. The best thing you can do is to take part in the action itself. Second best is to help out behind the scenes in the back-office group. To be involved, make sure you are on Telegram, and then we can put you into the right Telegram chat.
Another way to be involved now is to help us to contact people who have newly signed up for this newsletter. We like to phone people to welcome them to our group. With so many new people, we have a lot of calls to make – a terrific position to be in.
If you can help, please email xrwaverley@gmail.com
________________________________________

Local Extinction Rebellion groups in the Waverley and Borders area have, over time, been collaborating together successfully, tackling local issues and supporting each other in the XR national campaign for a more sustainable future. We are pleased to announce the merger of XR Guildford, XR Godalming, XR Farnham, XR Fleet, Farnborough and Camberley into a combined grouping. Our connective circle also benefits from the involvement of activists from many other towns and villages in the area, including Alton, Aldershot and Haslemere. Together we are stronger. We hope you will join us in being the change we want to see.
________________________________________
WEEKLY MEETINGS
WEDNESDAY 11th OCTOBER – Zoom meeting at 7.30pm
We encourage people attending for the first time to join the meeting at 7.15pm. Contact us for details of how to join.
We have a lot to talk about, including Oily Money Out, Farnborough Airport, reflection on recent actions and events.
Please join – share your views and help us plan!
18th Oct – The Plough, Farnham.
________________________________________
A NOTE FOR NEW READERS OF THIS NEWSLETTER
Firstly, thank you for being on our mailing list. We send a newsletter every week on Monday so that people know what’s happening in our local group, as well as in XR more broadly. We meet once a week on Wednesdays, mostly via Zoom and occasionally in person. Please join us for a meeting. A great way to do this for the first time is when we meet in person at The Plough in Farnham, which we do once a month. We do much of our communication, organisation and planning via Telegram, a messaging platform. If you want to join our Telegram chats, please email xrwaverley@gmail.com and we’ll get you set up. It’s a great way to be in touch.
_______________________________________
FARNBOROUGH AIRPORT

It’s probably not necessary to explain in this newsletter why flying is bad in general, and why private jets specifically are terrible. XR WAB rebels attended every one of the ‘consultations’ held by Farnborough Airport on their proposed expansion. Most of the public who turned up were angry about the airport’s plans. However, the campaign is nowhere near at an end and there are still things that everyone can do now.
FIRSTLY, sign Farnborough Noise Group’s petition started on Change.org and if you can, make a donation. Here’s the link.
For more information about the Farnborough Noise Group, which is about much more than just noise, go to their website. This contains excellent information about the damage caused by people who fly in private jets.
SECONDLY, complete the survey posted by Jules Crossley – a Rushmoor Borough Councillor, Shadow Climate Change Champion and the representative of local environmental groups on the Farnborough Aerodrome Consultative Committee – who is seeking views from the public on the Farnborough Airport expansion. You can find the survey here.
________________________________________
OILY MONEY OUT ACTIONS organised by FOSSIL FREE LONDON – 17th OCTOBER, 8am in London
Fossil Free London is a dynamic campaign group with a simple and very purposeful aim. They are great allies of XR. In October the annual Energy Intelligence Forum will be held in London where the biggest names in the fossil fuel industry come together for the ‘oil and money summit’ to celebrate their success – the ‘Oscars of Oil’.
If you’ve never joined a protest before, this is a great way to start your pathway to taking non-violent direct action. You will be with many other people as we come together in an act of solidarity and mass mobilisation.
XR UK are calling on all rebels and partner groups to join Fossil Free London in a day of disruptive action as we unite in numbers and do not move.
We are organising ourselves on Telegram. If you can join this action, please make sure you are on Telegram, and we can then get you into the relevant chat group. If you need help getting onto Telegram, please email xrwaverley@gmail.com.
The conference runs from the 17- 19th so if you can’t be there on the 17th please support Fossil Free London with other actions www.oilymoneyout.uk
________________________________________
WAB REBEL RHYTHMS – our amazing Samba band!
If you want to know what’s going on with WAB Rebel Rhythms or you want to join, go to the following webpage or email xrwaverley@gmail.com.
The band practices take place on the second Monday of the month from 6.30pm to 8.30pm at Milford Cricket Club, Milford Heath Road, Milford GU8 5BP.
What3words: https://w3w.co/pills.dimes.disco
________________________________________
What’s on at the Climate Emergency Centres
To find out what’s happening at What Next? in Waverley, use this link.
To find out what’s happening at Zero in Guildford, use this link.