Be an active bystander
January 27, 2025
In last week’s newsletter we talked about the mountain we have to climb having become steeper. We urged everyone who reads this newsletter to put on your climbing gear and go to the mountain. On Friday last week the campaign for action on the climate emergency had a setback when the government failed to host a free vote on the Climate and Nature Bill, kicking the legislation down the road until July 11th at the earliest, by which time it may be swamped by other parliamentary business. For an insight into the debate in the House of Commons, please read Clive and Beverley’s excellent report in this newsletter. The mountain just became steeper.
Trump’s assertion that his administration will ‘cleanse’ Gaza of Palestinians should alarm all of us. On the 80th anniversary of the liberation of those incarcerated at Auschwitz, Trump has endorsed ethnic cleansing. In the same few days, he has used bully-boy strong-arm tactics to force Colombia to take in deported refugees. Equally disturbing is the image from Brazil of deportees from the US arriving with hands cuffed and legs chained. Simply put, they were treated as criminals. This is how the new US administration is going to do business, with flagrant disregard for humanity, and for human dignity. This will be the case across all walks of life, so climate activists can expect no better. The mountain just became steeper.
We know what we are up against, so now is the time to act. There is often a concern when there is an emergency that too many people will be bystanders, most specifically passive bystanders, failing to take action at the time it is needed. Psychologists say that we are most in danger of becoming passive bystanders during emergencies when we are in the presence of others. The problem is compounded by the fact that the more passive bystanders there are, the less likely it is for anyone to take the action that the emergency requires. It’s described as a social and psychological paralysis. The good news is, you don’t have to be a passive bystander. You can be an active bystander!
There are numerous strategies suggested for going from being a passive to active bystander. There are two that are really pertinent for anyone unfamiliar with taking climate action. The first is not to be influenced by people who are doing nothing. The second is to become active in a group. The great thing is, we are a terrific group, and do not allow ourselves to be influenced by people doing nothing. Better still, we have pertinent actions coming up for everyone to join. We believe we can scale the mountain.
This week, on Wednesday morning a group of rebels will be out in Godalming for a ‘banner drop’. This is where we stand in a prominent point with either a lot of footfall, passing traffic or both, with a climate crisis themed banner or two. We do that to keep the climate crisis in people’s minds and let them know there’s a local XR group. If we can, we talk to people about who we are, what we do and how to join.
On Wednesday and Thursday there is a Defend the Juries/Free Political Prisoners action in London. This is hugely important given the criminalisation of peaceful climate protestors. In addition, we stand alongside all political prisoners. Details below.
On Saturday, Zero Carbon Guildford is hosting a South East Climate Alliance Annual Gathering. This brings together local groups to work together on the theme ‘A Call to Action’. Details available here.
On Sunday, we are back at Farnborough Airport to protest at the proposed increase in the number of flights per year. But we don’t just want to halt the increase in flights. No one should be allowed to fly in a private jet. For anyone to think it’s acceptable to burn the amount of fossil fuel it takes to get them into the air and to their destination is an unbelievably arrogant conceit. It should be illegal. Details of the actions are below.
As you can see, in the next few days there are plenty of actions to join, each one a step up the mountain. Make a decision to intervene, be an active bystander.
________________________________________
MEETINGS COMING UP
Meetings are planned for the coming months as follows:
5th Feb – Zoom (details next week)
19th Feb – in person at Zero Carbon Guildford where we are hosting a screening of the film Can I Live? (see below)
5th March – Zoom (details nearer the time)
19th March – in person (at a venue in Godalming)
We very much look forward to seeing as many people as possible at these meetings.
________________________________________
DEFEND OUR JURIES – 29th and 30th January
The next call for action for the Defend our Juries campaign is 29th and 30th January at the Royal Courts of Justice in London.

As Trudi Warner so eloquently put it; “this is a Crisis of Conscience”.
The draconian prison sentences against 16 Just Stop Oil members will be appealed in a historical hearing in January. This extraordinary appeal of a combined 41 years imprisonment is a major moment for those wrongly imprisoned, for our campaign and for the future of peaceful protest in the UK.
This all comes at a time when the legal pillar is already crumbling, with prisons and courts stretched to breaking point, and many of those working within the system deeply disillusioned. This is our time to come together across movements to show that people in this country don’t want protesters to be imprisoned.
Find out more about the attack on our civil liberties on the Defend Our Juries website, where you can also find information about any upcoming Zoom meetings to explain the campaign and actions.
_______________________________________
FARNBOROGH AIRPORT – SUNDAY 2nd FEBRUARY

Time: 10:30am.
Meeting point: car park on Ively Road/A327; GU14 0LJ Farnborough.
What3Words – https://w3w.co/winks.toxic.bake
We will have a short action briefing then walk to nearby Ively Gate at 10:45am.
Bring flags, posters, banners, drums and friends! Dress warmly and bring snacks to share. We will show the immensely wealthy 1% that private jets are not acceptable on a burning planet.
The decision by Rushmoor Council on the proposed increase of flights at Farnborough Airport was put on hold due to the general election. The plans haven’t gone away. We won’t go away either! There’s no need to go over the reasons why this is a really bad thing – just know, it’s a really bad thing!
________________________________________
CUT THE TIES – ACTION CALL OUT – MONDAY 17th FEBRUARY
Central London location.
Meet at 12 noon.

Following on from the highly successful Cut the Ties action at A&O Shearman, which featured lots of new faces, a lobby occupation, fire extinguishers with fake oil, the Oil Slickers , a theatrical grim reaper up a tripod and lots of smoke. Our biggest CTT action so far, but now it’s a new year and a new target. Based somewhere in Central London this target is another huge greenhouse gas enabler, brazenly profiting from expanding fossil use worldwide. Their greed is undermining all the hard work put in by people working hard to save our only living planet. We will be dressing in hazard overalls to form a human chain, holding banners, handing out leaflets and pressuring this climate destroying company to Cut The Ties to Fossil Fuels!
Tell us you are coming in the Cut The Ties Telegram group.
________________________________________
FILM SCREENING OF CAN I LIVE? – Wednesday 19th February

XRWAB, with Zero Carbon Guildford, is hosting a showing of Can I Live ? at Zero on Wednesday 19th February at 7.30pm.
Can I Live? is a rap and spoken word performance about the climate crisis through the lens of a young Black British artist and activist – an energising exploration of the place where the climate emergency and social justice meet.
Inspired by Fehinti Balogun’s experiences in environmental activism, Can I Live? is an uplifting performance and is a call-to-arms to anyone who may have felt excluded from activism or is curious about how to get involved.
Please book tickets via this link and share widely amongst friends, family and other groups you are involved with.
________________________________________
Report from Parliament – Second Reading CAN Bill 24th Jan 2025
We reached the special gallery of the House of Commons by walking under the impressive hammerbeam roof of Westminster Hall. We felt a connection as this roof was crafted locally in Farnham in the 14th century. The gallery allows a good view of most of the Commons chamber and we were pleased that a large number of MPs had delayed their return to their constituencies for this second reading of the Climate and Nature Bill.
Roz Savage, Liberal Democrat MP for South Cotswold, spoke with determination for 40 minutes as she laid out the need for combined legislation that joined both climate change and nature restoration in one legally binding package. She particularly supported nature friendly farmers, wanted to create more interconnected open spaces and emphasised the need for the urgent delivery of tree planting and wildlife reintroduction. On climate, her emphasis included the decarbonisation of transport and buildings, support for the Sunshine solar panel bill and new water conservation measures. Whilst deserts are expanding, soil is degrading and nature is depleted, there is still hope. We need to unlock our passion for nature. Quoting William, aged 10, Roz said “What you do here today will change my life”
Drawing on her experience of rowing single handed across the Atlantic, Pacific and Indian oceans, she said, she has learnt that the earth is very small for its almost 8 billion inhabitants. We are gobbling through its resources; low level islands are going to disappear and the cost of action will be far less than the consequences of inaction. The choice is ours.
Roz and all the other campaigners were thanked by the Labour MP Clive Lewis as he launched into an excellent and dynamic speech supporting the Bill. Speaking without notes he was very critical of his own party for not offering its support. Growth should not be achieved at the expense of nature and agreeing with an intervention from Daisy Cooper MP for St Albans, airport expansion is incompatible with the climate emergency. He made it clear that if you get growth in an unequal society it all goes to the top 5%.
Next came a speech by Sir Roger Gale, an older Conservative. He supported the Bill because he cared about the younger generations and missed the abundant wildlife of his own youth. He opposed Drax and worried about future food shortages in the UK.
Barry Gardiner MP Labour remarked on the long history of this Bill. He discussed people’s Assemblies and stated that Drax should not be subsidised as it took us on completely the wrong road.
Another Conservative MP, Simon Hoare, gave a supportive and at times, amusing speech explaining that as the apex species, what we do matters. He said growth should not be achieved at the cost of nature, but that we need to thrive by removing red tape on renewables and embracing green technology. He concluded by quoting Margaret Thatcher’s remarks on climate change. “We need to make changes and sacrifices.” “We should be led by science and the facts”
Alice Macdonald LibDem MP was concerned about flooding in east Anglia, but proud that so much wind power was being generated off their coastline. She mentioned Citizens Assemblies, the need for sustainable growth, joined up action and maintaining cross part unity.
Shadow Minister Andrew Bowie Conservative for Aberdeenshire enthusiastically praised the previous government for their climate and nature achievements. He would have supported the Bill, but had concluded that its contents would damage jobs and UK industry with its green levies, extra taxes and lower growth. This provoked an intervention from another MP who quoted the recent report by actuaries that said our present path would reduce our GDP by 50%. Macdonald continued by condemning climate assemblies, stating that this was not our way of doing things and that we could not outsource our decisions to an unelected body. He said the Bill would put great pressure on the economy and that fossil fuels will still need to be imported if we do not extract our own. The bill had many inconsistencies and would do great harm. Unsurprisingly, he could not support the Bill.
Next up was an emotional speech from Carla Denyer the Bristol Green Party MP. She said that we all win if this Bill is passed but that this was not going to happen. This was our first indication in the House that there was not going to be a vote on the CAN Bill. She said that the Bill had been traded for a meeting with the Minister and a video. She disagreed with this and still wanted a vote that day. She felt the Bill was sound and that it should go to the next stage.
Roz Savage explained that she had been negotiating with the government right up until the night before, but they were not going to allow it to progress as they were preparing their own legislation. She had concluded that it was better to maintain cross party support than to lose a vote that would mean the end of the Bill’s objectives. Nardia Whittome LibDem co-sponsor of the Bill agreed that the transitional demands that had been won were worth keeping by not having a vote.
Whilst we digested this news, Lizzie Collinge Labour stated that we needed to be resilient in the face of the coming climate changes and dangers and Greg Smith Conservative announced that renewables were actually a danger to nature. Making changes that go too far and too fast would export jobs. Other MPs said that the future looks dire and that a rapid transition was needed to take advantage of the immense economic opportunities of green energy.
The final stage of the debate was delivered from the dispatch box by the government minister Mary Creagh. She acknowledged the huge efforts made by the Bill’s sponsor Roz Savage. She shared her passion for climate and nature but was sure that it needed full cross-party agreement if it was to achieve its broad aims. The late John Prescott was mentioned as a Labour MP who managed to salvage an agreement at the Kyoto COP. The minister acknowledged that we were living through an age of extinction where we needed a circular economy and sustainable growth. Plus, special measures to strengthen water regulations, ocean protection, more coastal defences, better land use, more tree planting and an improved infrastructure. The government is committed to a carbon emissions reduction of 81% by 2035.
The day ended with no vote on the Bill but with a promised return to the House on 11th July 2025.
This was a lively, passionate and civilised debate by all parties, but it appears that the outcome had already been decided the day before, possibly because its measures would legally commit the government to actions that it felt it could not afford.
We returned home, greatly disappointed that despite all the campaigning by Greenpeace, Zero Hour and many others, the well-attended galleries, the many protesters waiting outside in the heavy rain and even a protest choir inside Westminster Hall, we were not going to see this vital Bill progress to the next stage.
Beverley and Clive
I want to share with you an inspiring answer in the CAN Bill debate by conservative MP Simon Hoare to the argument ..why should we do this if others aren’t ?
“I say to him respectfully that if the rest of the world does something that is to the good, and one or two countries decide not to, or go at a slower pace or on a different path, I do not believe we should just stop, shrug, throw it up in the air and say, “Oh, well, if not everybody’s doing it, why the hell should we?” We led the abolition of slavery. Nobody else was doing it. We did it because we thought it was right. We introduced factory Acts. Nobody else was doing it. We did it because we thought it was right. We introduced votes for women. [Interruption.] Not me personally! I am not as old as my hon. Friend; I have just had a hard life.
We have led. It is what the United Kingdom does. We are not a nation that follows; we are a nation that sculpts, leads, forms, challenges, cajoles and encourages.”
(From Hansard)
________________________________________
WAB REBEL RHYTHMS – our amazing Samba band!
We would love to have more players in the Samba band. Please get in touch to join in. You can find out more at the following webpage or email xrwaverley@gmail.com.
The band practices take place on the second Monday of the month from 6.30pm to 8.30pm at Milford Cricket Club, Milford Heath Road, Milford GU8 5BP.
What3words: https://w3w.co/pills.dimes.disco
________________________________________
What’s on at the Climate Emergency Centres
To find out what’s happening at What Next? in Waverley, use this link.
Zero is now in new premises at the top of Guildford High Street – to find out more, use this link.