The Jevons Paradox

Humans have been wise for a very long time, and stupid for an equally long time. In the mid-nineteenth century, the economist William Stanley Jevons theorised that however much more efficient we make our engines and machines, we would find new excuses to burn just as much, if not more coal. Welcome to the Jevons Paradox. We live this every day. In car manufacturing, for example, being able to make cars from increasingly lighter materials (thinner steel, monocoque construction, lightweight plastics, aluminium engine parts etc.) hadn’t resulted in lighter cars. It’s resulted in bigger cars using lighter materials and weighing more than previously built smaller cars. The surge in recent years of SUVs is a classic case in point and has resulted in an overall increase in vehicle emissions despite, technically, cars being more efficient. As we transition from fossil-fuel to electric vehicles, the point is lost if the majority of vehicles are SUVs. The knock-on emissions cost in manufacture, and the knock-on increase in electricity required to power them offsets the potential gain in the switch to EVs.

Even when EVs, or other electrical apparatus, are charged with renewable energy, that hasn’t come at a zero fossil-fuel cost. The blades of wind turbines are often made of materials such as glass fibre, that are based on oil products. The steel base for an offshore wind farm requires huge amounts of energy to be used in blast furnaces. As we increase our move to renewables, we do this in the belief that we are getting something free from or with limited environmental impact. It seems that it’s ok to use unlimited amounts of energy because it’s ‘renewable’. But electrification comes at a high environmental cost too. It requires huge amounts of copper and steel – the basic building blocks of the vast number of turbines that are needed to create electricity. Similarly, solar panels contain rare-earth materials, as well as an abundance of silicon, silver, aluminium and copper. It’s easy to see now why the conclusion to a war may be negotiated around minerals. And why people are looking to the ocean floor for nuggets of copper and other metals. Drill, baby, drill may be the mantra, but everyone knows the future lies elsewhere.

Let’s keep the Jevons Paradox in mind – it may be an observation made 160 years ago, but it has a place today. Just because we are transitioning from fossil fuels to energy generated by electricity doesn’t mean we can keep producing more, growing our economies, and assuming that because something is called clean, or renewable, or sustainable, that it comes without environmental consequences.

We know, from all the evidence around us, that we are trashing the planet. However, it’s not great being in a doom loop. If you want to hear the positive stuff that is happening, then you can do a lot worse than to watch Simon Clark’s video on YouTube How much progress have we made on climate change? We’re not making the progress we need to, but positive things are happening.

Because we are not making the progress we need to, XR continues to have a vital role in accelerating change, campaigning against the biggest carbon emitters, and fighting for the other world we want to see. At a local level, we will go back to Farnborough Airport soon. We are continuing with the Cut the Ties campaign. We will continue to support the Defend our Juries actions. We will pick up on our Dirty Water campaign – Thames Water is not out of the woods. At a national level, there are no large-scale actions currently announced. In the meantime, XRUK is putting on a lot of training. Details of some of these are given below. Please take the time to look at these and to attend some.

This week we have an in-person meeting in Godalming, with a social as much as a planning focus. It would be lovely to see new people there so please do come along.

________________________________________

MEETING THIS WEEK

19th March – in person in Godalming. We will meet at the Denningberg Centre and will be hosted by What Next? (climate emergency centre for Waverley). The venue is next to the Borough Hall opposite Waitrose – (what3words rents.firmy.toast). If coming bay car, don’t park in the Waitrose car park. There’s a 90-minute time limit and they use number plate recognition. People are caught out!

The focus of in-person meetings is social. We will also discuss plans for upcoming actions and meetings from now and through the summer.

We very much look forward to seeing as many people as possible at these meetings.

________________________________________

DEFEND OUR JURIES ACTION AT A CROWN COURT NEAR YOU!

Trudi Warner’s action at Inner London Crown Court two years ago started the whole amazing Defend our Juries campaign. This is an ongoing campaign, both during trials of climate activists and at other times. There are plans for local actions coming up, the details of which we won’t share in this newsletter. If you are interested in the campaign for justice, then please join the relevant Telegram group – there is a link posted via the general chat. If you need help with this, please email xrwaverley@gmail.com. 

________________________________________

MONDAY 7th APRIL – CUT THE TIES ACTION, LONDON

Following the fantastic CUT THE TIES action at McKinsey, the next CUT THE TIES action is in the works!

We don’t broadcast the details of these actions in the newsletter, we are pretty guarded on Telegram too. When we know the meeting point, we’ll let you know. There is a Cut The Ties Telegram chat if you want to get information that way. Email xrwaverly@gmail.com if you want to be added to it.

________________________________________

GET INVOLVED IN XR

If you would like to be more involved in XR, and not sure where to start, there are online events created just for you. Sessions are being held as follows:

Sun 23 Mar, 19.00–20.00        

Tues 8 April, 19.00–20.00        

Mon 21 April, 15.30–16.30 

Register for any session here: https://xrb.link/PJ0hSs4v4 Info about the complementary talk, ‘Intro to XR’, is in the registration link above. 

Facebook event (23 Mar, with links to other dates): https://xrb.link/CI262rml87M 

For pre-session queries, please contact: volunteer@extinctionrebellion.uk

Be part of the change you want to see.

________________________________________

OPPRESSION, MOVEMENT BUILDING AND OUR RELATIONSHIPS AS ACTIVISTS ONLINE WORKSHOP

Thurs 27 Mar, 19.00–22.00 

Join our online interactive workshop on oppression, movement building and our relationships as activists, covering: why activists too often end up fighting each other rather than working together how to address classism, sexism, racism, etc. in ways that don’t create further division space for personal sharing and experience of practical tools Facilitators: Karl & Alima Register here: https://xrb.link/m668X3Ut ️

 Facebook event: https://xrb.link/vx6GQ58F Questions? email: ombraworkshop@gmail.com

________________________________________

WAB REBEL RHYTHMS – our amazing Samba band!

We would love to have more players in the Samba band. Please get in touch to join in. You can find out more at the following webpage or email xrwaverley@gmail.com.  

The band practices take place on the second Monday of the month from 6.30pm to 8.30pm at Milford Cricket Club, Milford Heath Road, Milford GU8 5BP.

What3words: https://w3w.co/pills.dimes.disco

________________________________________

What’s on at the Climate Emergency Centres

To find out what’s happening at What Next? in Waverley, use this link.

Zero is now in new premises at the top of Guildford High Street – to find out more, use this link.