Newsletter 14th September

This newsletter originally went out to our mailing list at 08:15 on 21st September. If you’d like to be added to the mailing list please contact us.

On almost a daily basis a new report highlights either the escalating climate end ecological crisis, or the woefully insufficient action being taken by governments to tackle the crisis. On Monday the Green Alliance published its latest ‘Net Zero Policy Tracker’. Politicians will hang on to some of its positives such as the opening sentence that reads: the UK has a strong track record of climate ambition. Not only was it the first major economy to set a legally binding 2050 net zero target, but it was also one of the first countries to commit to phase out coal powered energy.

However, the reality is, as we know, that fine words and ambitions are no substitute for effective action, and in that regard the government is found to fall short. The report goes on to point out that our calculations show the UK is a long way off track to meet its 2050 net zero carbon target. Policies in place at the start of this government left an emissions gap of 985 MtCO2e over the fifth carbon budget period (2028-32). Policies and spending announced since will only reduce emissions by 24 per cent, still leaving a significant gap of 746 MtCO2 e. Bear in mind that many people, including XR, argue that a net zero target by 2050 is actually nowhere near ambitious enough to avoid mass extinction.

The report sets out positives and negatives across a range of domains and while it’s good to know where progress has been made, the negatives are of such a basic nature that it beggars belief they exist at all. They include not pushing through the environment bill, failing to cease all new road building projects, planning further north sea oil exploration that will emit the CO2 equivalent of running 16 coal fired power stations, delays to the hydrogen strategy, no policies to reduce demand for road and aviation transport, and no home decarbonisation strategy.  The impossible rebellion highlighted the extent to which the tide is turning and people now support our campaign. People recognise the government’s shortcomings now that XR and other groups have pointed them out.

We are still reflecting on the rebellion and when we have done that, we will turn our attention to what we do next. How do we push on so that even more people support what we do? How do we use the ongoing reports about the crisis we face as leverage with the public and government? What form of credible alternative to ‘business as usual’ can we present locally and nationally? What actions will we take in relation to COP26? The tide is turning, time to hoist the sails…

____________________

CONTENTS

  • Meeting this week
  • Forthcoming meetings
  • From the wellbeing group
  • Other actions
  • Victor’s reflections on a day of rebellion

____________________

MEETING THIS WEEK

This week’s meeting is on Wednesday 15 September via Zoom.

The meeting will start at 7.15 pm for anyone who hasn’t attended one of our meetings before who may want to chat before we start. The meeting is open to all rebels from Godalming, Farnham, Guildford and any others who are in the London WAG Telegram group.

The main meeting will start at 7.30pm

For Zoom meeting details contact us.

Details about the format of the meeting are given below.

____________________

FORTHCOMING MEETINGS

Meetings for the next few weeks will vary between being in-person and on zoom. The emphasis right now is on listening and sharing as people continue to take the opportunity to rest and de-brief the experience of rebellion in London.

Last Wednesday we met under the bandstand in the park in Godalming. Probably as a result of all feeling a little addled after the London rebellion, we hadn’t worked out that it would be raining and dark by 8pm! Nevertheless a group of us enjoyed spending time together and reflecting on our experiences of the past fortnight. We began the process of debrief, using the XR standard model of roses, thorns and buds – a rose being equivalent to something you felt went well, a thorn something which didn’t go well, and a bud representing a learning or suggestion for the future.

This Wednesday we’ll meet on zoom and will again have some space for check-ins in breakout group, more time for de-brief using the roses, thorns, buds model, and some time to just begin to think about what might be next. The following week we’ll look to have another in-person meeting, venue to be decided, with the emphasis more on “ok, so what next?”

The meetings continue to be open to all, including those from other XR groups who joined us in ‘WAG’ affinity group and including those who did not take part in the rebellion. The debrief is not a linear process, but more one on which a useful perspective emerges from a process of feedback, reflection, thinking and more feedback: please DON’T feel that if you’ve already engaged in one debrief season you shouldn’t attend another one. The process of collaborative reflection and learning is helped by different combinations of voices (and ears!). We’re keeping notes of outcomes and will ensure that different threads of reflection and feedback are woven together in a useful whole at the end.

With that in mind, anyone who wants to put some de-brief thoughts in writing, please feel free to do so. This can be in addition to or instead of feedback you give at a meeting. If you want to do this please send to xrgodalming@gmail.com and if possible use the Roses, Buds, Thorns format as above (but if you want to tell us something in a different format we’d like to hear that too). In meetings or in writing, feedback can focus on any aspects of the rebellion (e.g. could be how the actions in London were organised, could be about your experience of this group, specific things or general things) – whatever you want to tell us, we want to hear it.

Finally, feel free to respond individually to any requests for feedback you might have seem on regional Telegram groups or received from XR national via email. Once we’re able to summarise our own ‘group response’ we will do that and send it to the relevant places – in the meantime it’s fine and good to have your individual say too: as we all found with the process of organisation of actions in London, the multi-channelled XR process can be confusing and at times annoying, but if we trust it quite often something beautiful and powerful emerges.

____________________

FROM THE WELLBEING GROUP

Those in the Wellbeing working group would like to remind everyone (including themselves!) of the importance of rest , self-care and regeneration at this time, and also to let you know, in case you didn’t already, that you can email us anytime at gxrwellbeing@gmail.com  If there’s something you need to share with us or ask for – whether this is about emotional or practical support of some kind – please get in touch and we’ll try to help. Additionally, the Wellbeing working group is always keen to hear suggestions of how we can all do our best to look after ourselves and each other and, of course offers to join us in the working group.

____________________

OTHER ACTIONS

By way of information, and in case people want to find out more or participate, here’s a couple of non-XR groups doing thing nationally and locally:

Youth Strike for Climate

Youth Strike for Climate has an even in Guildford on 24th September. More information is available via their Instagram page.

Insulate Britain

Insulate Britain (IB) hit the news on Monday when they blocked junctions on the M25. They have two demands demand to help overcome the climate crisis:

  1. That the UK government immediately promises to fully fund and take responsibility for the insulation of all social housing in Britain by 2025;
  2. That the UK government immediately promises to produce within four months a legally binding national plan to fully fund and take responsibility for the full low-energy and low-carbon whole-house retrofit , with no externalised costs, of all homes in Britain by 2030 as part of a just transition to full decarbonisation of all parts of society and the economy.

IB is not part of XR, although XR members may well be involved. XRUK has put out a statement about IB.

____________________

VICTOR’S REFLECTIONS ON A DAY OF REBELLION

Saturday 4th September.

Today, thousands of members of XR gathered at Trafalgar Square for a march under the title of ‘March For Nature’, many dressed in nature-inspired costumes, many carrying placards calling for defence of the natural world to be given the urgent priority that it needs. Sadly, for far too long, nature has not been given the protection from mankind that it needs: our rivers are being polluted daily with human and animal excrement, and industrial chemical spills, such that in 2020, not one river or lake in the UK was deemed to be in good health; our government still appears to be willing to wage chemical warfare upon pollinators; our Marine Protected Areas have been failed by the Marine Management Organisation which has prevented bottom trawlers from decimating the seabed, and, according to the Mammal Society, 25% of the UK’s native mammals are at risk of extinction.

This march was marked by an increased presence of children, some in costumes or masks depicting the animals that they love, some holding signs declaring their concerns for nature, and all accompanied by adults, strongly aware of the way that mankind’s activities are devastating the living environment and hastening our own destruction at the hands of the 6th mass extinction.

I had spent my visits to London during the two weeks of rebellion, engaging people in conversation on the streets, and from that, learning that there are many who hold deep concerns about mankind’s relentless destruction of our planet. Towards the end of the march, I was acutely aware that I had one last thing to do, which had been weighing upon mind and sapping my courage: I had agreed to support a friend who would undertake a rebellion of one (RO1). This entails a ‘sitter’ taking a position in a road, in order to stop the traffic, with a sandwich board bearing a message describing their fears for the future, due to the climate and ecological crises. These protests (in my experience) tend to last 30 minutes, before the police arrive, but during that time, many are drawn by curiosity to discover what is happening, and why. The sitter only undertakes this particularly daunting action because they are utterly convinced that far greater danger, public inconvenience and serious disruption are waiting for us on road of destruction, along which mankind is racing, with its foot still hard on the floor.

It had been a long day of standing around and then marching; my energy was low, my anxiety was rising, and as we reviewed our options for where the 2 sitters would take their place, I felt that I wasn’t strong enough now to be a supporter, but encouragement kept me with the group.

A crossroads was identified, and a decision was made as to where the sitters would take their place. Perhaps it was partly the adrenalin, but far more likely it was the desire to support those whose determination now energised me that I followed closely, now ready to support them. And suddenly, without any awareness that this was coming, things changed for me, and my thoughts cleared, my fears evaporated, and determination empowered me as I put one of the spare signs, which I had carried all day, around my own neck, and took a place behind my friends on the road. In all, 6 of us sat or knelt in this junction, declaring to everyone that this is a climate and ecological emergency.

After returning from London, with the constant recollection of our group action still spinning wildly in my head, I found the following quote by Martin Luther King Jr. The first three questions will guide you accurately through each of my own (previously held) personal objections to taking such an action as this (objections that I had delivered to a good friend who was preparing to take an RO1 action, alone, in Farnham). It’s clear to me now, that it is the final question that ejected me from my comfort zone:

Cowardice asks the question – is it safe?

Expediency asks the question – is it politic?

Vanity asks the question – is it popular?

But conscience asks the question – is it right?

And there comes a time when one must take a position that is neither safe, nor politic, nor popular; but one must take it because it is right. Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr.

With hope and determination,

XR Godalming